Snowden: The Deep State’s Influence On The Presidency

Famed whistleblower Edward Snowden was recently interviewed by the Italian publication, La Repubblica. The publication noted the 5-year mark of Snowden’s historic act of blowing the whistle on the NSA’s expansive surveillance programs and that “many thought he would end up very badly".

But when he connects via video-link for this interview with la Repubblica, he seems to be doing very well: the frank smile and peaceful face of someone who is easy in his mind.”

Snowden explained how the presidencies of both Obama and Trump are shaped by the Deep State following an illuminating question by journalist Stefania Maurizi.

Stefania Maurizi: We saw that President Obama, who was an outsider to the US military-intelligence complex, initially wanted to reign in the abuses of agencies like the CIA and the NSA, but in the end he did very little.

Now we see a confrontation between president Trump and so-called Deep State, which includes the CIA and the NSA. Can a US president govern in opposition to such powerful entities?

Edward Snowden: Obama is certainly an instructive case. This is a president who campaigned on a platform of ending warrantless wiretapping in the United States, he said “that’s not who we are, that’s not what we do,” and once he became the president, he expanded the program.  

He said he was going to close Guantanamo but he kept it open, he said he was going to limit extrajudicial killings and drone strikes that has been so routine in the Bush years. But Obama went on to authorise vastly more drone strikes than Bush. It became an industry.

As for this idea that there is a Deep State, now the Deep State is not just the intelligence agencies, it is really a way of referring to the career bureaucracy of government.

These are officials who sit in powerful positions, who don’t leave when presidents do, who watch presidents come and go, they influence policy, they influence presidents and say: this is what we have always done, this is what we must do, and if you don’t do this, people will die.

It is very easy to persuade a new president who comes in, who has never had these powers, but has always wanted this job and wants very, very badly to do that job well.

A bureaucrat sitting there for the last twenty years says: I understand what you said, I respect your principles, but if you do what you promised, people will die.

It is very easy for a president to go: well, for now, I am going to set this controversy to the side, I’m going to take your advice, let you guys decide how these things should be done, and then I will revisit it, when I have a little more experience, maybe in a few months, maybe in a few years, but then they never do.

This is what we saw quite clearly happen in the case of Barack Obama: when this story, of Snowden exposing the NSA’s mass surveillance, came forward in 2013, when Obama had been president for five years, one of the defences for this from his aides and political allies was: oh, Obama was just about to fix this problem! 

And sure enough, he eventually was forced from the wave of criticism to make some limited reforms, but he did not go far enough to end all of the programs that were in violation of the law or the constitution of the United States.

That too was an intentional choice: he could have certainly used the scandal to advocate for all of the changes that he had campaigned on, to deliver on all of his promises, but in those five years he had become president, he discovered something else, which is that there are benefits from having very powerful intelligence agencies, there are benefits from having these career bureaucrats on your side, using their spider web over government for your benefit.

Imagine you are Barack Obama, and you realise, yes, when you were campaigning you were saying: spying on people without a warrant is a problem, but then you realise: you can read Angela Merkel’s text messages. Why bother calling her and asking her opinion, when you can just read her mind by breaking the law?

It sounds like a joke, but it is a very seductive thing. Secrecy is perhaps the most corrupting of all government powers, because it takes public officials and divorces them from accountability to the public.

When we look at the case of Trump, who is perhaps the worst of politicians, we see the same dynamic occurring. This is a president who said the CIA is the enemy, it’s like Nazi Germany, they’re listening to his phone calls, and all of these other things, some claims which are true, some claims which are absolutely not.  A few months later, he is authorising major powers for these same agencies that he has called his enemies.

And this gets to the central crux of your question, which is: can any president oppose this?  The answer is certainly. The president has to have some familiarity going in with the fact that this pitch is going to be made, that they are going to try to scare him or her into compliance.

The president has to be willing to stand strongly on line and say: ‘I was elected to represent the interests of the American people, and if you’re not willing to respect the constitution and our rights, I will disband your agency, and create a new one’. I think they can definitely be forced into compliance, because these officials fear prison, just like every one of us.

Eurasia Review:

Snowden Says Social Media Is Surveillance 'Rebranded':

« Australia’s Cybersecurity Adviser Calls For Privacy
The US Power Grid Needs Better Security »

Infosecurity Europe
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

DigitalStakeout

DigitalStakeout

DigitalStakeout enables cyber security professionals to reduce cyber risk to their organization with proactive security solutions, providing immediate improvement in security posture and ROI.

Alvacomm

Alvacomm

Alvacomm offers holistic VIP cybersecurity services, providing comprehensive protection against cyber threats. Our solutions include risk assessment, threat detection, incident response.

ZenGRC

ZenGRC

ZenGRC (formerly Reciprocity) is a leader in the GRC SaaS landscape, offering robust and intuitive products designed to make compliance straightforward and efficient.

NordLayer

NordLayer

NordLayer is an adaptive network access security solution for modern businesses — from the world’s most trusted cybersecurity brand, Nord Security. 

Clayden Law

Clayden Law

Clayden Law advise global businesses that buy and sell technology products and services. We are experts in information technology, data privacy and cybersecurity law.

XBOSoft

XBOSoft

XBOSoft is a software QA and testing company. We cover the entire QA and testing life cycle including software and application security.

Vaddy

Vaddy

Vaddy provide an automatic web vulnerability scanner for DevOps that performs robust security checks to ensure that web app code is secure.

Korea Internet & Security Agency (KISA)

Korea Internet & Security Agency (KISA)

KISA is committed to improving the competitiveness, reliability and security of Internet information and knowledge in Korea.

BeOne Development

BeOne Development

BeOne Development provide innovative training and learning solutions for information security and compliance.

Atlantic Council Digital Forensic Research Lab (DFRLab)

Atlantic Council Digital Forensic Research Lab (DFRLab)

The Atlantic Council’s DFRLab has operationalized the study of disinformation by exposing falsehoods and fake news, documenting human rights abuses, and building digital resilience worldwide.

Netsafe

Netsafe

Netsafe is an independent, non-profit New Zealand organisation focused on online safety. We help people stay safe online by providing online safety education, advice and support.

Clari5

Clari5

Clari5 redefines real-time, cross channel banking Enterprise Fraud Management using a central nervous system approach to fight financial crime.

SOCOTEC Certification International

SOCOTEC Certification International

SOCOTEC Certification International has been providing management systems assessment and accredited ISO certification services to organisations around the world since 1995.

Irish National Accreditation Board (INAB)

Irish National Accreditation Board (INAB)

INAB is the national accreditation body for Ireland. The directory of members provides details of organisations offering certification services for ISO 27001.

Right-Hand Cybersecurity

Right-Hand Cybersecurity

Right-Hand Cybersecurity empowers businesses to monitor, measure and mitigate employee induced cyber risks in real-time.

RapidScale

RapidScale

RapidScale’s managed cloud solutions provide reliable, innovative, and secure services, all complete with white-glove service and full management options.

Stairwell

Stairwell

Stairwell is building a new approach to cybersecurity around a vision that all security teams should be able to determine what’s good, what’s bad, and why.

Siometrix

Siometrix

Siometrix addresses digital identity fraud. It steals your attacker's time and prevents many prevalent attack vectors.

Offensive Security Manager (OSM)

Offensive Security Manager (OSM)

Offensive Security Manager is the ultimate AI software that will enforce offensive security automation, orchestration, coverage, ensure quality, and lets you manage whole process.

Excite Cyber

Excite Cyber

Excite Technology Services (formerly Cipherpoint) is focused on improving the security posture of our customers.

Reco AI

Reco AI

Reco is an identity-centric SaaS security solution that empowers organizations with full visibility into every app, identity, and their actions to control risk in their SaaS ecosystem.