A Cashless Society? Be Careful What You Wish For

Cash is being rapidly dethroned as increasing numbers of countries focus on digitalizing their economies. Scandinavian countries are leading the way, with Denmark seeking to be cashless by 2030.

Denmark’s central bank has already stopped manufacturing physical money and around a third of the nation’s population already uses Danske Bank’s mobile payment system. Even Copenhagen’s mobile street food vendors are readily accepting contactless payments. In Sweden, 95% of the country’s retail transactions are digital, banks are ceasing to hold cash and redundant ATMs are being removed from the streets.

Global tech giants such as Apple and Google are making single ‘tap’ payments ubiquitous. Whilst authorities have been quick to laud the benefits of a cashless society, this convenience is not without its dangers – constant surveillance and massive personal data collection and storage, as well as complete dependence on government imposed fiscal policy.

One benefit of digitized currencies is their relative cost effectiveness in comparison to cash, which is expensive to produce, maintain and handle. It costs twice the coins’ monetary value to produce American cents and nickels, leading a McKinsey survey to conclude digitizing the US currency would increase the nation’s GDP by almost 0.5%. Significant costs are accrued in secure transportation and handling – influencing the Danish government’s view that cash imposes too many ‘administrative and financial burdens’ on retail businesses.

Already suspicion surrounds requests for cash-in-hand payment, now associated with tax avoidance and criminality. A world without cash would see reduced tax avoidance and minimized underground markets, especially useful in countries like Greece where tax evasion is endemic.

Cash has always fuelled Black Markets (although the equally anonymous yet digital Bitcoin did have its reputation tarnished following its use as the payment method for Silk Road, an online dark-net platform for purchasing narcotics, which was shut down by the FBI in 2013) so the eradication of cash would reduce this type of crime. However, as one area of financial crime diminishes, significant increases in cyber crime and identity theft occur. A stolen £20 note carries no personal information, whereas breaches of digital accounts not only provide access to funds but also a host of personal details.

Losing physical cash is annoying, but losing identity information could be devastating; whole accounts wiped and details used to open fraudulent bank accounts and to apply for credit. Sweden provides a good example of the crime problems faced in an almost cashless economy – in the past 10 years card fraud cases have doubled, and between 2000 and 2011 instances of digital monetary fraud increased six fold. Practically no digital server is incorruptible or immune to hacking, and it would be worryingly naive to think the reduction of physical financial crime would necessarily outweigh the dangers of digital crime.

You do not need to be in possession of aggressively Libertarian views to recognize that a cashless society requires the relinquishing of freedom. A cashless society could be almost Orwellian with regard to the control a government would possess over its population. Denmark’s goal is a central bank responsible for all current accounts, with any international bank branches drawing funds from this central bank rather than individual depositors.

Whilst in stable, democratic nations it is hard to imagine a situation where this control is leveraged by the government to manipulate the population, such as limiting access to funds in the face of strikes, in corrupt and dictatorial regimes, ultimate governmental control over access to funds could be especially dangerous – whole currencies could be invalidated, payments declined, funds frozen. An electricity outage, either deliberate or unavoidable, could immobilize the funds of a whole population.

A cashless economy would also place the population’s deposits at the total mercy of fiscal policymakers. The list of nations with negative interest rates for financial institutions is ever growing – with the Bank of Japan introducing negative rates last week. This penalty for holding cash overnight will trickle down, until depositors of both high and low value are affected. With $2trn of bonds trading globally with negative interest, some investors have begun to liquidate portions of their investments – including a selection of Swiss pension funds that have moved the majority of their investments into cash.

Having an entire nation’s accounts in a single, central institution would provide authorities with total control over the public’s economic behaviour. Whilst this is beneficial from an economist’s point of view, countries could more effectively control economic fluctuations, few people are wholly comfortable with the prospect of their money being subjected to negative rates as and when the government wants to stimulate spending and increase the ‘velocity of money’. When saving is preferable, negative interest would be dropped and perhaps even transaction taxes implemented.

Jim Leaviss, Head of Retail Fixed Interest for M&G’s mutual fund range, and an advocate of a cashless society, claimed ‘such an approach would be a far more effective way to dampen an overheated economy than today’s blunt tool of a rise in the central bank’s official interest rate’. It may be more sensible from a purely economic view, but human populations rarely behave or think as economists do – and any implementation of this policy would, and should, be greeted with scepticism.

Ultimately we are the victims of our own demand for convenience. Digital currencies are not being forced upon us; we have an insatiable demand for quicker, more convenient payments and services. An economy untethered from physical cash would be initially beneficial for all, but is it worth allowing governments to gather startling quantities of personal data, forcefully directing our financial habits, and potentially making a nation’s bank accounts vulnerable to fraud? Does the convenience and ease of a digital currency, from the point of the public, really outweigh everything we would have to sacrifice? I suspect not.

Olivia Townsend is a graduate in History from the University of Oxford, providing fresh perspectives on current trends and issues.

CapX: http://bit.ly/1UERzad

« One Ethicist’s Compromise To Stop Killer Robots
Cyber Criminals Have Evolving Tactics »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

CYRIN

CYRIN

CYRIN® Cyber Range. Real Tools, Real Attacks, Real Scenarios. See why leading educational institutions and companies in the U.S. have begun to adopt the CYRIN® system.

LockLizard

LockLizard

Locklizard provides PDF DRM software that protects PDF documents from unauthorized access and misuse. Share and sell documents securely - prevent document leakage, sharing and piracy.

NordLayer

NordLayer

NordLayer is an adaptive network access security solution for modern businesses — from the world’s most trusted cybersecurity brand, Nord Security. 

BackupVault

BackupVault

BackupVault is a leading provider of automatic cloud backup and critical data protection against ransomware, insider attacks and hackers for businesses and organisations worldwide.

Cyber Security Supplier Directory

Cyber Security Supplier Directory

Our Supplier Directory lists 6,000+ specialist cyber security service providers in 128 countries worldwide. IS YOUR ORGANISATION LISTED?

CERT-In

CERT-In

CERT-In is a functional organisation of the Ministry of Information & Electronics Technology, Government of India, with the objective of securing Indian cyber space.

iLand

iLand

iland is a global cloud service provider of secure and compliant hosting for infrastructure (IaaS), disaster recovery (DRaaS), and backup as a service (BaaS).

Zivaro

Zivaro

Zivaro provides transformational consulting and technology services to help clients attain real business value from their technology investments.

Aspisec

Aspisec

Aspisec is a cybersecurity company specialized in Firmware Security and Critical Infrastructure Protection.

CyPhyCon

CyPhyCon

CyPhyCon is an annual event exploring threats and solutions to cyber attacks on cyber-physical systems such as industrial control systems, Internet of Things and Industrial Internet of Things.

Norwest Venture Partners (NVP)

Norwest Venture Partners (NVP)

Norwest Venture Partners offer entrepreneurs a broad range of services to help them build their businesses at every stage of growth. Key sectors include AI, Infrastructure, SaaS and Security.

QNu Labs

QNu Labs

QNu Labs’s quantum-safe cryptography products and solutions assure unconditional security of critical data on the internet and cloud across all industry verticals, globally.

BIO-key

BIO-key

BIO-key is a pioneer and innovator, we are recognized as a leading developer of fingerprint biometric authentication and security solutions.

VariQ

VariQ

VariQ is a premier provider of Cybersecurity, Software Development and Cloud services to federal, state, and local government.

Acreto

Acreto

Acreto is an end-to-end security infrastructure that protects all your technologies with a single, simple cloud service.

Force Majeure

Force Majeure

Force Majeure specializes in cybersecurity, incident response, and digital forensics, with experience spanning more than a decade.

Global Resources

Global Resources

Global Resources' planning and management capabilities support city, regional, and national utility and infrastructure management, and information systems and cyber security service delivery.

Sentrium Security

Sentrium Security

Sentrium is committed to helping organisations protect their technology, information and people. Our range of bespoke services provide solutions to tackle a broad range of cyber security challenges.

Vircom

Vircom

With a large majority of cyber attacks starting with email, Vircom provides protection against the worst email security threats to your business.

Moro Hub

Moro Hub

Moro Hub, a subsidiary of Digital DEWA, is a UAE-based digital data hub focused on digital transformation and operational services.

Blue Bastion

Blue Bastion

Don’t give cybercriminals the chance to find weaknesses in your company’s cyber security system. Defend your institution from all attacks from all directions with Blue Bastion.