A Predictive Tool For Armed Police

Police operations will be able to use behavioral data and get warning signs that a police officer may be breaking the force’s rules and is about to shoot an unarmed civilian.

To build the algorithms that may one day be able to create a sort of “risk score” for police, researchers are using familiar tools: data from police body cameras and squad cars, and the internal reports usually kept locked in police departments away from researchers, including information on officer suspensions and civilian complaints.

Of all this information, body cameras, which were purpose-built to create an objective and unaltered record of an officer’s every move on the job, may be the most valuable. At least in theory: Since the Justice Department began offering $ millions in grants for body cameras in 2015 and advocates began clamoring for the technology, police have claimed their cameras have fallen off and become unplugged or blew-up and the footage deleted.

But the push to use body cameras on police now has a surprising source: the camera industry itself. Late April, Axon, the No. 1 manufacturer of body cameras in the United States, announced its Performance tool, which is seemingly targeted at the long line of high-profile body-camera failures.

The tool, a paid upgrade for current customers, is a dashboard that quantifies how often officers turn their cameras on during calls and whether they categorise videos correctly.

Axon’s announcement came just after a jury convicted the Minneapolis police officer Mohamed Noor of shooting and killing an unarmed civilian, the Australian-born yoga instructor Justine Damond. The case is among the most high-profile incidents of police violence that involved body-camera failure.

While both Noor and his partner wore body cameras the night Damond was shot, neither was turned on to record the shooting. Shannon Barnette, the sergeant on duty and Noor’s supervisor, was the first to arrive on the scene after Damond’s death. Footage from her body camera is split into three parts.

In the first, she drives to the scene. In the second, she approaches another officer; says “I’m on,” presumably referring to her body camera; and then turns the camera off. The footage resumes two minutes later. Prosecutors asked Barnette why her camera was turned off, then on. “No idea,” Barnette responded. He testified that the department’s policy on when the cameras are supposed to be on was “not clear” at the time. Since the shooting, the Minneapolis Police Department has revised its policy: The cameras stay on.

Lauren Haynes, the former associate director of the Center for Data Science and Public Policy at the University of Chicago, helped design a statistical model to predict when officers may become involved in an “adverse event,” anything from a routine complaint up to an officer-involved shooting. The project didn’t use the kind of body-camera data that Axon’s new tool works with, but she says they’re “absolutely something that could be put into the model.”

The team found that a number of stressors were related to those adverse events, including whether officers worked a second job, whether they took too many sick days, and whether they’d recently responded to a domestic-violence incident or a suicide. Place matters, too: Officers were more likely to be involved in an adverse event if they were sent into neighborhoods far from their usual beat.

Haynes thinks it’s possible that officers won’t be completely opposed to the idea of risk scoring. “If it comes off as a punitive thing, people are going to be against it,” she says. On the other hand, if the scores are presented as a tool to keep departments from pushing officers too hard, the plan might gain some support.

“You want to put people in the right interventions for them,” Haynes says. “There are all kinds of different solutions depending on what the specific risk is.”

Predictive tools have an inherent risk. They offer only the probability of any event happening. They could be wrong or even dangerous, creating feedback loops that penalize officers who seek counseling, for example. Cameras and algorithms offer potential tools for police accountability, but don’t ensure it.

DefenseOne:

You Might Also Read:

Smartphones Are Working For Dutch Police:

 

 

« US Army Identifies How To Improve Cybersecurity
Digital Advertising Is A $Billion Ripoff »

Infosecurity Europe
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

NordLayer

NordLayer

NordLayer is an adaptive network access security solution for modern businesses — from the world’s most trusted cybersecurity brand, Nord Security. 

Syxsense

Syxsense

Syxsense brings together endpoint management and security for greater efficiency and collaboration between IT management and security teams.

BackupVault

BackupVault

BackupVault is a leading provider of automatic cloud backup and critical data protection against ransomware, insider attacks and hackers for businesses and organisations worldwide.

Infosecurity Europe, 3-5 June 2025, ExCel London

Infosecurity Europe, 3-5 June 2025, ExCel London

This year, Infosecurity Europe marks 30 years of bringing the global cybersecurity community together to further our joint mission of Building a Safer Cyber World.

ManageEngine

ManageEngine

As the IT management division of Zoho Corporation, ManageEngine prioritizes flexible solutions that work for all businesses, regardless of size or budget.

Black Hat Briefings

Black Hat Briefings

The Black Hat Briefings are a series of highly technical information security conferences that bring together thought leaders from all facets of the infosec world.

Trend Micro

Trend Micro

Trend Micro is a leader in hybrid cloud, endpoint, and network security solutions.

Telefonica Tech

Telefonica Tech

Telefónica Cyber Security Tech is focused on the prevention, detection and appropriate response to security incidents aimed at protecting your digital services.

InfoWatch

InfoWatch

InfoWatch solutions allow you to protect data and information assets that are critically important to your business.

Industrial Cyber Security

Industrial Cyber Security

Industrial Cyber Security provides specialist consulting services in enterprise and SCADA system security.

NRD Cyber Security

NRD Cyber Security

NRD Cyber Security create a secure digital environment for countries, governments, and organisations and implement cybersecurity resilience enhancement projects around the world.

Recorded Future

Recorded Future

Recorded Future arms security teams with threat intelligence powered by patented machine learning to lower risk.

Cybersprint

Cybersprint

Cybersprint's Digital Risk Protection platform continuously monitors your digital footprint so you can make informed decisions on exposure to online threats, identify vulnerabilities and take action.

Tesorion

Tesorion

Tesorion is a fusion of different enterprises each with its own specialisation in the field of cybersecurity. We have combined these specialisations to create an integrated comprehensive solution.

ISA Security Compliance Institute (ISCI)

ISA Security Compliance Institute (ISCI)

ISCI, a not-for-profit automation controls industry consortium, manages the ISASecure™ conformance certification program for industrial automation and control systems.

TrueFort

TrueFort

TrueFort take an application-first approach that offers comprehensive protection for real-time visibility and analysis, protection and better communication across business, IT, and security teams.

Cyber Security Operations Consulting (CyberSecOp)

Cyber Security Operations Consulting (CyberSecOp)

CyberSecOp is an ISO 27001 Certified Organization which provides cyber security operations services and risk management consulting.

Cybeta

Cybeta

Cybeta's actionable cybersecurity intelligence keeps your business safe with strategic and operational security recommendations that prevent breaches.

SRG Security Resource Group

SRG Security Resource Group

SRG Security Resource Group is a Canadian company dedicated to providing world-class Physical and Cyber Security services.

Centroid

Centroid

Centroid is a cloud services and technology company that provides Oracle enterprise workload consulting and managed services across Oracle, Azure, Amazon, Google, and private cloud.

Elastio

Elastio

Elastio's cloud-native platform safeguards cloud data from the risks posed by ransomware, application failures and storage security vulnerabilities.