Artificial Intelligence Distorts Government Decision-Making

It is widely predicted that Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning (ML) will transform government structures, economies and political systems around the world, across western democracies and authoritarian regimes of every stripe. 

AI will certainly increase the impact false information the future, generating convincing fake news at scale.

The challenges to democracies such as the United States and EU nations are becoming apparent as increased polarization in social media and the online world promotes political division. The challenges to autocracies are more subtle but possibly more corrosive.

Just as AI reflects and reinforces the divisions of democracy, it may also confound autocracies, creating a false appearance of consensus and concealing underlying social fissures until it is too late.

Early pioneers of AI, including the political scientist Herbert Simon, realised that AI technology has more in common with markets, bureaucracies, and political institutions than with simple engineering applications. 
Another pioneer of artificial intelligence, Norbert Wiener, described AI as a “cybernetic” system, one that can respond and adapt to feedback. Neither Simon nor Wiener anticipated how machine learning would dominate AI, but its evolution fits with their way of thinking.

Facebook and Google use machine learning as the analytic engine of a self-correcting system, which continually updates its understanding of the data depending on whether its predictions succeed or fail. It is this loop between statistical analysis and feedback from the environment that has made machine learning such a formidable force.

What is much less well understood is that democracy and authoritarianism are cybernetic systems, too. Under both forms of rule, governments enact policies and then try to figure out whether these policies have succeeded or failed. In democracies, votes and voices provide powerful feedback about whether a given approach is really working. Authoritarian systems have historically had a much harder time getting good feedback. Before the information age they relied not just on domestic intelligence but also on petitions and clandestine opinion surveys to try to figure out what their citizens believed. 

Now, AI is disrupting traditional forms of democratic feedback (voices and votes) as new technologies facilitate disinformation and worsen existing biases, taking prejudice hidden in data and confidently transforming it into false assertions. To authoritarian regimes, AI looks like a very welcome opportunity. 

Such technology can tell rulers whether their subjects like what they are doing without the hassle of surveys or the political risks of open debates and elections. For this reason, many observers have fretted that advances in AI will only strengthen the hand of dictators and further enable them to control their societies. The truth is more complicated.

Bias is visibly a problem for democracies. But because it is more visible, citizens can mitigate it through other forms of feedback. Authoritarian countries are probably at least as prone to bias as democracies are, perhaps more so. Much of this bias is likely to be invisible, especially to the decision-makers at the top. That makes it far more difficult to correct, even if leaders can see that something needs correcting.

Contrary to conventional wisdom, AI can seriously undermine autocratic regimes by reinforcing their own ideologies and fantasies at the expense of a finer understanding of the real world. Democratic countries may discover that, when it comes to AI, the key challenge of the twenty-first century is not winning the battle for technological dominance.

Instead, they will have to contend with authoritarian countries that find themselves in the throes of an AI-fueled spiral of delusion.

Foreign Affairs:        DaysTech:     Reddit:       Flipboard:     EUI - Guriev & Treisman:

You Might Also Read: 

Artificial Intelligence Will Change The Future Of The World:


 

« Why Domain Protection Is A Key Pillar Of Cybersecurity
Even Air-Gapped Computers Are Vulnerable To Attack »

Infosecurity Europe
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

CYRIN

CYRIN

CYRIN® Cyber Range. Real Tools, Real Attacks, Real Scenarios. See why leading educational institutions and companies in the U.S. have begun to adopt the CYRIN® system.

LockLizard

LockLizard

Locklizard provides PDF DRM software that protects PDF documents from unauthorized access and misuse. Share and sell documents securely - prevent document leakage, sharing and piracy.

NordLayer

NordLayer

NordLayer is an adaptive network access security solution for modern businesses — from the world’s most trusted cybersecurity brand, Nord Security. 

Clayden Law

Clayden Law

Clayden Law advise global businesses that buy and sell technology products and services. We are experts in information technology, data privacy and cybersecurity law.

Authentic8

Authentic8

Authentic8 transforms how organizations secure and control the use of the web with Silo, its patented cloud browser.

Redcentric

Redcentric

Redcentric is a leading UK IT managed services provider. We deliver managed IT, cloud computing, data backup, information security services and managed networks.

Owl Cyber Defense

Owl Cyber Defense

Owl patented DualDiode Technology enables hardware-enforced network segmentation and deterministic, one-way transfer of all data types and file sizes.

Samsung Knox

Samsung Knox

Samsung Knox brings multi-layered defence-grade security to your business’s smartphones and tablets.

Pluribus One

Pluribus One

Pluribus One develops customized solutions and other data-driven applications to secure your business and your devices.

Careerjet

Careerjet

Careerjet is a leading online job search engine with a large presence worldwide, sourcing millions of job ads from thousands of websites from all over the world in areas including Cybersecurity.

Northcross Group (NCG)

Northcross Group (NCG)

NCG provides services to help organizations meet the challenges of regulatory compliance. Our services include support, consultation, tools and accelerators for all parts of an organization.

e-Careers

e-Careers

e-Careers is an edtech institution that provides industry recognised courses and up-skilling solutions to individuals and organisations.

CrossCountry Consulting

CrossCountry Consulting

CrossCountry Consulting is a trusted business advisory firm that provides customized finance, accounting, human capital management, risk, operations and technology consulting services.

Rausch Advisory Services

Rausch Advisory Services

Rausch delivers solutions that address compliance, enterprise risk, information technology and human resource capital.

RMC

RMC

RMC was purpose-built for Mission Assurance and ICS/OT cybersecurity, dedicated to strengthening and protecting government and commercial assets.

ZoobeTek

ZoobeTek

ZoobeTek are a company focused on preventing leaks related to the security of business information3.

Astran

Astran

At Astran, we revolutionize data security by introducing a groundbreaking solution for data confidentiality headaches.

Ark Technology Consultants

Ark Technology Consultants

Ark Technology Consultants is a unique IT Services Firm which blends technology solutions with consultative insight around governance and process management.

Interlock

Interlock

Interlock are building blockchain-based security products that solve legacy web2 security issues - phishing and social engineering.

ThreatMate

ThreatMate

ThreatMate empowers businesses with comprehensive tools to detect, protect, and remediate against cyber threats.

Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution (BfV)- Germany

Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution (BfV)- Germany

The Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution (Bundesamt für Verfassungsschutz - BfV) is the domestic intelligence services of the federal government of Germany.