Bitcoin Developer Says Cryptocurrency Has Failed

A senior bitcoin developer has declared the cryptocurrency a failed experiment, blaming the end of the currency on the refusal of the community to adopt new standards, which would allow it to grow consistently while maintaining stability.

Mike Hearn, a longtime senior developer on bitcoin and the former chair of the bitcoin foundation’s law and policy committee, announced in a blogpost that he would be selling his coins and quitting development on the project. “Despite knowing that bitcoin could fail all along, the now inescapable conclusion that it has failed still saddens me greatly,” he wrote.

Hearn’s objections to the current state of bitcoin are varied and frequently technical in nature, but at heart there are two failures: the section of the bitcoin community with power over the future of the currency is overly centralised and overly resistant to change.

Hearn writes that: “What was meant to be a new, decentralised form of money that lacked ‘systemically important institutions’ and ‘too big to fail’ has become something even worse: a system completely controlled by just a handful of people.”
There are two important bottlenecks in bitcoin’s organisational structure: the developers and the miners.
The former group are those people with the authority to make changes to the released version of bitcoin (the “core”). Although bitcoin is open source software, meaning anyone is free to use it or tweak it into a new system, there is still only one official release of it.
Anyone can propose changes to that release, but only five people have the authority to actually put those changes into the released version – and those five have been hopelessly split for the past six months about how to deal with bitcoin’s capacity problems as it grows.

The split has become so bad that Gavin Andresen, the most senior of the developers, paired with Hearn in August to attempt to launch a “hard fork” of bitcoin, which would use the same basic code but fix some of the capacity constraints. That launch merely exacerbated the split, however, with people who supported the new version (dubbed bitcoin XT) being blacklisted by the supporters of the old version.

But the main reason why XT never took off was the failure of the other major bottleneck: the miners.

Bitcoin is supposed to be a decentralised currency. Anyone can download the entire history of bitcoin transactions, and devote computing power to verifying future transactions (called mining). For a change such as the switch to XT to succeed, more than half of the computing power on the bitcoin network has to support it by updating their-own software accordingly.

But very few people bother to mine for bitcoin. It’s expensive in terms of computer hardware, time and electricity so it is very difficult to beat professionally equipped outlets in the race for rewards. Those amateurs who do mine largely do so as part of pools, who share both computing power and rewards. Those pools, however, are also centrally controlled.

As a result, Hearn points out, just two individuals control more than 50% of the power of the network. He adds that “over 95% of hashing power was controlled by a handful of guys sitting on a single stage” at a recent bitcoin conference.
For their own reasons, the miners, who are largely based in China, are reluctant to switch to a competing implementation of bitcoin, or push for changes.

As a result, Hearn writes, bitcoin is seeing ever-greater congestion in the network, which it is unable to cope with in its present form. And the institutional failure to accept changes means that confidence in the currency is declining. “The fundamentals are broken and whatever happens to the price in the short term, the long term trend should probably be downwards”, Hearn writes.

Guardian:

« Is the US Ready For Cyberwar?
‘I Hacked Citrix’ - Mystery Russian ‘w0rm’ »

ManageEngine
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Check Point

Directory of Suppliers

IT Governance

IT Governance

IT Governance is a leading global provider of information security solutions. Download our free guide and find out how ISO 27001 can help protect your organisation's information.

NordLayer

NordLayer

NordLayer is an adaptive network access security solution for modern businesses — from the world’s most trusted cybersecurity brand, Nord Security. 

Keygraph

Keygraph

Keygraph builds AI penetration testing for application security teams. Keygraph also builds Shannon, a leading open-source AI pentester

CSI Consulting Services

CSI Consulting Services

Get Advice From The Experts: * Training * Penetration Testing * Data Governance * GDPR Compliance. Connecting you to the best in the business.

RELIANOID

RELIANOID

RELIANOID provides advanced Application Delivery and integrated security solutions to protect and optimize critical digital services.

ANS Group

ANS Group

ANS are a strong team of straight-talking tech and business experts. Our mission is to make digital transformation accessible to all.

NQA Certification

NQA Certification

NQA provides certification to a range of ISO standards including ISO 27001 for information security management.

Forensic Control

Forensic Control

Forensic Control specialise in providing simple & straightforward Cyber Security to organisations, helping them assess, prevent and respond to cyber threats.

Mega

Mega

Mega is a secure cloud data storage provider with browser-based high-performance end-to-end encryption.

NRI Secure Technologies

NRI Secure Technologies

NRI SecureTechnologies is a Cybersecurity group company of the Nomura Research Institute (NRI) and a global provider of next-generation Managed Security Services and Security Consulting.

Signifyd

Signifyd

Signifyd is the world's largest provider of Guaranteed e-Commerce Fraud Protection.

Cybint Solutions

Cybint Solutions

Cybint provides customized cyber education and training solutions for Higher Education, Companies and Government.

BeDefended

BeDefended

BeDefended is an Italian company operating in IT Security and specialized in Cloud and Application Security with years of experience in penetration testing, consulting, training, and research.

Celerium

Celerium

Celerium transforms cyber defense for both companies and industry sectors by leveraging cyber threat intelligence to defend against cyber threats and attacks.

SyncDog

SyncDog

SyncDog is a leader in enterprise security and the preeminent vendor for containerized mobile application security across cloud & on-premise computing environments.

Foundries.io

Foundries.io

Foundries.io have built a secure, open source platform for the world's connected devices, and a cloud service to configure this to any hardware and any cloud.

Zephyr Project

Zephyr Project

The Zephyr Project strives to deliver the best-in-class RTOS for connected resource-constrained devices, built to be secure and safe.

Swissbit

Swissbit

Swissbit AG is the leading European manufacturer of storage, security and embedded IoT solutions for demanding applications.

Hawk AI

Hawk AI

Hawk AI’s mission is to help financial institutions detect financial crime more effectively and efficiently using AI to enhance rules and find anomalies.

SGS Brightsight

SGS Brightsight

SGS Brightsight is the largest independent security evaluation lab in the world, with ten recognised labs worldwide.

Orchid Security

Orchid Security

Orchid Security provides unprecedented insight and action to your identity security with the help of advanced technologies like Large Language Models (LLM).