British Police Continue A Secret Snowden Investigation

A secret British police investigation focusing on journalists who have worked with Edward Snowden’s leaked documents is still active more than four years after it was launched.

The investigation, codenamed “Operation Curable”, is being led by a counter-terrorism unit within London’s Metropolitan Police, under the direction of the force’s head of Specialist Operations, Mark Rowley. The Metropolitan Police confirmed the status of the investigation in response to a Freedom of Information Act request.

The disclosure that the probe remains active prompted criticism on from the National Union of Journalists, the UK’s largest journalists’ organisation. Sarah Kavanagh, a spokesperson for the group, said that news reports based on the Snowden documents had exposed unlawful covert surveillance activities in the public interest.

“The media are often the only group in society able to reveal the intelligence and security forces have exceeded their legitimate powers and remit,” Kavanagh said. 
“The Met Police should be condemned for keeping journalists under investigation because they worked on the Snowden leaks. The investigation should be halted immediately. Journalism is not a crime.”

The origins of the investigation can be traced back to May 2013, when Snowden, a National Security Agency contractor, turned over a cache of classified documents about government surveillance to journalists, including Intercept co-founder Glenn Greenwald. Among the documents were details about mass surveillance programs operated by the UK’s largest spy agency, Government Communications Headquarters, or GCHQ.

In August 2013, detectives from the Metropolitan Police used a counterterrorism law to detain and interrogate David Miranda, Greenwald’s partner (both pictured), while he was passing through London’s largest airport. 

Miranda was carrying a batch of encrypted Snowden documents to aid Greenwald’s reporting on the files. The police seized Miranda’s possessions, including a mobile phone, laptop, camera, and flash drives, and began a criminal investigation.
British authorities argued that publishing the Snowden files was itself a terrorist act, thereby explicitly conflating journalism with terrorism. Prior to Miranda’s arrival in London, a memo authored by the Metropolitan Police and domestic spy agency MI5 was circulated to UK border entry points. 

It asserted that “the disclosure of the Snowden documents, or threat of disclosure, is designed to influence a government and is made for the purpose of promoting a political or ideological cause. This therefore falls within the definition of terrorism.”
In December 2013, one of the London force’s most senior officers, Cressida Dick, was questioned about the case during a parliamentary hearing. 

She acknowledged that the force’s investigation was looking at whether reporters at The Guardian had committed criminal offenses, some carrying potential 10-year prison sentences, for their role in revealing secret surveillance operations exposed in the documents. “We need to establish whether they have or haven’t [committed offenses,” Dick said. “That involves a huge amount of scoping of material.” Later, however, the Metropolitan Police attempted to keep all details about the case secret. In early 2015, the force refused to confirm or deny whether the investigation existed, and stated that revealing such details could help terrorists and be “detrimental to national security.” 

The force eventually backed down on this position and admitted the probe remained ongoing, following an intervention from the UK’s Information Commissioner’s Office, which enforces freedom of information laws in the country. Given that the investigation has been active for more than four years, it appears likely that it has required a substantial amount of resources at a time when the Metropolitan Police has faced budget cuts and had to respond to a spate of terror attacks in London. 

The force has declined to provide any information about the amounts of funds spent on the probe, or disclose the number of officers working on it, insisting that it does not hold records of these details. A spokesperson for the Metropolitan Police said in a statement that the investigation “was launched in order to protect life and national security.” 

The spokesperson added: “As would be as expected we do not put a time limit on an investigation, and the priority is that it is thorough and establishes all of the relevant facts. This is a complex investigation and enquiries continue. No arrests have been made to-date.”

In 2016, a judge ruled that the UK’s counterterrorism legislation did not sufficiently protect the rights of journalists, after Miranda sued the police for detaining him at the London airport. 

The judge found that Schedule 7 of the Terrorism Act, the power used to target Miranda and seize his possessions, was “not subject to adequate safeguards against its arbitrary exercise” and was “incompatible” with Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which protects the right to “receive and impart information and ideas without interference by public authority and regardless of frontiers.”

The Intercept

You Might Also Read: 


 

 

« The Role Of Russian Influence In The Brexit Referendum Is Unclear
UK Police Give Cybercrime Warning »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

Syxsense

Syxsense

Syxsense brings together endpoint management and security for greater efficiency and collaboration between IT management and security teams.

Clayden Law

Clayden Law

Clayden Law are experts in information technology, data privacy and cybersecurity law.

NordLayer

NordLayer

NordLayer is an adaptive network access security solution for modern businesses — from the world’s most trusted cybersecurity brand, Nord Security. 

Resecurity, Inc.

Resecurity, Inc.

Resecurity is a cybersecurity company that delivers a unified platform for endpoint protection, risk management, and cyber threat intelligence.

CYRIN

CYRIN

CYRIN® Cyber Range. Real Tools, Real Attacks, Real Scenarios. See why leading educational institutions and companies in the U.S. have begun to adopt the CYRIN® system.

TrustedIA

TrustedIA

TrustedIA - safeguarding your business, it's critical assets, information, reputation and brand.

Cloud Foundry Foundation (CFF)

Cloud Foundry Foundation (CFF)

Cloud Foundry supports the full application development lifecycle, from inception, through all testing stages, to deployment.

National Authority Against Electronic Attacks (NAAEA) - Greece

National Authority Against Electronic Attacks (NAAEA) - Greece

The National Authority Against Electronic Attacks (NAAEA) is the national computer emergency response team of Greece.

Cosan

Cosan

Cosan is a cybersec solutions & services provider that assists organisations to identify vulnerabilities, protect sensitive data and remain compliant.

Galois

Galois

Galois specializes in the research and development of new technologies that solve the most difficult problems in computer science.

Digital Guardian

Digital Guardian

Digital Guardian is a next generation data protection platform designed to stop data theft.

OSIRIS Lab - NYU Tandon

OSIRIS Lab - NYU Tandon

The Offensive Security, Incident Response & Internet Security Lab (OSIRIS) is a security research environment where students analyze and understand how attackers take advantage of real systems.

Protectimus

Protectimus

Affordable two factor authentication (2FA) provider. Protect your data from theft with multi factor authentication service from Protectimus.

LightEdge Solutions

LightEdge Solutions

LightEdge’s highly-trained compliance and security experts take the guesswork out of keeping your business protected.

Flipside

Flipside

Information Security training provider specialized in personalized training and security awareness campaigns.

Maven Technologies

Maven Technologies

Maven Technologies specialize in secure data destruction, electronics recycling, asset management, and highly detailed reporting.

Delfigo Security

Delfigo Security

Delfigo Security, a pioneer in intelligent authentication, provides a strong, multi-factor authentication solution to prevent identity theft and reduce fraud.

Vietnamese Security Network (VSEC)

Vietnamese Security Network (VSEC)

Vietnamese Security Network (VSEC) is an information security company providing website vulnerability scanning and monitoring services.

Ostra Cybersecurity

Ostra Cybersecurity

As a next-generation MSSP, Ostra Cybersecurity combines best-in-class tools, proprietary technology and exceptional talent to deliver Fortune 100-level protection for businesses of all sizes.

Noerr

Noerr

Noerr is one of the top European law firms with 500 professionals in Germany, Europe and the USA. We provide solutions to complex and sophisticated legal matters including cyber risks.

Traced

Traced

TRACED is changing the detection paradigm. Empowering defenders to go on the offense to engage cyber attackers before they compromise your organization.