Drone Operators’ Jobs Are Safe From Robots…For Now

 

A typical drone combat air patrol, or CAP, is a lot more manpower-intensive than the term “unmanned aerial vehicle” would suggest. In fact, as many as 150 people—from repairmen to image analysts—play some sort of role in every drone flight that takes place over Iraq and Syria. It’s a problem created by technology. Unfortunately, it’s not a problem that technology is going to solve any time soon, according to Steven K. Rogers, the senior scientist for automatic target recognition and sensor fusion at the Air Force Research Laboratory.

Rogers is leading efforts to reduce the amount of manpower needed to fly those combat air patrols by moving the state of technology forward. “To give you an idea of the state of the art in this space,” he told a group at the GEOINT Symposium on Monday in downtown Washington, D.C., “I have young airmen, analysts— they are ordered, ‘You stare at that screen. You call out anything you see, if you need to turn your eyes for any reason, you need to sneeze, you need to ask permission, because someone else has to come put their eyes on that screen.’ The point I’m driving home to you is that the state of the art in our business is people… The diversity of these tasks means that quite often, we throw together ad hoc combinations of sensors and people and resources to find information we need.”

The Pentagon is putting a huge emphasis on autonomy for tasks like intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance. When former Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel announced the Defense Innovation Initiative last November, he named robotics and autonomous systems as keys to military innovation. The initiative is part of the so-called “offset strategy,” a bid to develop new silver-bullet technologies to secure military dominance for decades to come.
Says Rogers: “Every place through those documents you see autonomy, autonomy, autonomy.”
His message to the brass is this: manage your expectations. Extra computational power and “slight improvements in algorithms won’t solve the autonomy problems,” he says.
What’s so hard about autonomy? It’s not that machines can’t see and it’s not that they can’t think. What they lack is imagination; that ability is central even to tasks like target recognition, which would seem not to require it.
“Imagined representation is key to autonomy,” says Rogers.
In essence, that refers to the ability to fill in gaps in data and rapidly construct new mental models of external situations. It requires a very high level of mental adaptability, even when there seems to be more than enough data at hand.
“To do autonomy, I have to be able to handle when I don’t have all the information that I need, or I don’t have the right mental model. That’s what we have to push on to achieve autonomy. “ he says.  “Figuring out what’s going to happen next, it’s not sensor data populated, it’s an imagined representation.”
Artificial intelligence agents can “figure out what’s going to happen next” only in extremely limited domains, ones they’ve experienced or learned about by structured data that they’ve been fed. You can program a machine to anticipate every possible chess move but not to understand how a human will feel about losing at chess to a machine.

Humans are constantly constructing new models of the world, recognizing patterns, on the basis of lived experience. In fact, everything you think will happen is a projection based in part on something that’s already happened to you. PalmPilot creator Jeff Hawkins dubs this the “memory prediction framework.”
“The brain uses vast amounts of memory to create a model of the world. Everything you know and have learned is stored in this model. The brain uses this memory-based model to make continuous predictions of future events. It is the ability to make predictions about the future that is the crux of intelligence,” Hawkins writes in On Intelligence: How a New Understanding of the Brain will Lead to the Creation of Truly Intelligent Machines, his seminal book on the automation of human thinking

Intelligence, thus, is the ability to collect data and know what the data is even at the moment it is being collected, so that the intelligent agent can change the way that data is used, it is knowing through anticipating. Within the human brain, that processing happens immediately and constantly thanks, in part, to the neocortex, the new brain that our pre-mammalian ancestors evolved more than 50 million years ago. It’s the neocortex that allows humans to fill in holes in sensed data with stuff from memory in order to make an imagined representation of a future event, to complete a pattern, to predict. This is the precisely the challenge that autonomy for intelligence collection represents.

Without some sort of major technological breakthrough, full autonomy for intelligence collection – for example, replacing human eyes on that drone feed — will be impossible, says Rogers. Science is scoring scattered victories. “Tracking? We’re here and there, depending on the environment.  That’s going to keep improving.  But target recognition? I have job security. We’ve thrown billions of dollars at that and we don’t have it yet.”
DefenseOne: http://bit.ly/1GChRPf

 

« Hackers target Polish airline carrier LOT
5 Facts that Explain Cyber Warfare »

ManageEngine
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Check Point

Directory of Suppliers

Directory of Cyber Security Suppliers

Directory of Cyber Security Suppliers

Our Supplier Directory lists 8,000+ specialist cyber security service providers in 128 countries worldwide. IS YOUR ORGANISATION LISTED?

ManageEngine

ManageEngine

As the IT management division of Zoho Corporation, ManageEngine prioritizes flexible solutions that work for all businesses, regardless of size or budget.

Lunar

Lunar

Lunar is a free, enterprise-grade, compromised-credentials monitoring platform, available to every company, everywhere.

IT Governance

IT Governance

IT Governance is a leading global provider of information security solutions. Download our free guide and find out how ISO 27001 can help protect your organisation's information.

Keygraph

Keygraph

Keygraph builds AI penetration testing for application security teams. Keygraph also builds Shannon, a leading open-source AI pentester

Imperva

Imperva

Imperva is a leading provider of data and application security solutions including DDoS protection, Web application security, Data security and Cloud security.

Cristie Data

Cristie Data

Cristie have been a trusted, innovative and leading edge data storage, backup and virtualisation solutions provider across all sectors of industry for over 40 years.

DataLocker

DataLocker

DataLocker offers both hardware based external storage and software based cloud storage encryption solutions.

Basis Technology

Basis Technology

Basis Technology provides software solutions for text analytics, information retrieval, digital forensics, and identity resolution.

Invensis Learning

Invensis Learning

Invensis Learning is a professional training and certification company providing IT Service Management, IT Security & Governance, DevOps, Cloud Computing and Digital Awareness training.

Wizlynx Group

Wizlynx Group

Wizlynx services cover the entire risk management lifecycle from security assessments and compliance to the implementation of security solutions and provision of Managed Security Services.

Hardenite

Hardenite

Hardenite solution helps R&D, DevOps and IT teams to continuously manage security risks and hardening efforts of any Linux OS – based product, throughout the product life cycle.

CoverWallet

CoverWallet

CoverWallet combines deep analytics, thoughtful design and state of the art technology to help small businesses with all their insurance needs including Cyber Liability.

Foundries.io

Foundries.io

Foundries.io have built a secure, open source platform for the world's connected devices, and a cloud service to configure this to any hardware and any cloud.

Vala Secure

Vala Secure

Vala Secure is a cybersecurity and compliance consultancy that always stays ahead of regulations, future threats and ever-changing security environments.

Moro Hub

Moro Hub

Moro Hub, a subsidiary of Digital DEWA, is a UAE-based digital data hub focused on digital transformation and operational services.

Leo CybSec

Leo CybSec

Leo CybSec unites a group of Cyber Security experts with 20+ years of collective expertise to help our clients realise and mitigate the cyber challenges and risks facing their business.

BuddoBot

BuddoBot

BuddoBot has been a pioneering force in cybersecurity and information technology since 2008.

BugDazz

BugDazz

BugDazz pentest as a service (PTaaS) platform helps bringing in real-time results, detail coverage, & easy remediation workflows with compliance-ready reports.

3ReSen

3ReSen

3ReSen prioritizes innovative and compliant cybersecurity, systems and software engineering and flexible, futureproof data systems and management.

Huskeys

Huskeys

At Huskeys, we’re redefining the role of WAF in modern organizations. We add the intelligence layer that makes existing WAFs adaptive, measurable, and revenue-aware.