Convergence & Digitalisation Create Problems For Energy Utilities

The convergence of previously separate sectors around renewable smart grids is creating an expansive energy value chain with widely divergent cyber security practices and vulnerabilities, eroding organisational control over energy security.

A failure to consolidate cyber security practices and policies across this new diverse value chain could result in cyber attacks causing operators severe financial and reputational damage. Fear of cyber attacks has already been found to affect consumer take-up of smart meters and poor security could hamper the success and adoption of smart grids. 

The scale of the threat is demonstrated by a recent rise in ransomware attacks targeting energy networks; from pipelines to power grids. 

Weak Links In The Energy Value Chain

Smart grids are driving the convergence of the energy and technology sectors to create efficient, flexible grids that balance supply and demand based on live data. This renders energy grids dependent on the security practices of a wide variety of third-party technology companies; from cloud providers to smart infrastructure suppliers.

The result is that responsibility for grid security is increasingly dispersed among a wider array of organisations than ever before.

Any infrastructure is only as secure as the weakest link in its supply chain, and this ever-expanding green energy ecosystem creates a bigger patchwork of cyber security vulnerabilities. Many of these suppliers now need continued access to their customer energy networks to perform remote maintenance and monitoring of energy assets, creating more potential vulnerabilities. And new energy infrastructure often interfaces with legacy infrastructure which was never designed for connectivity.

If the old, centralised energy grids resembled large walled castles with just a few gateways, the current energy system more closely resembles a multitude of mini castles with many intricate interconnections between them.

Edge Devices Create A Porous Perimeter

Edge devices such as smart appliances to sensors on grid infrastructure. These are made by an array of technology suppliers with varying standards of security, creating a diverse and distributed array of potential attack vectors.

This is further compounded by the fact that some manufacturers are sacrificing security for speed to market and rushing out new smart appliances with limited security features. As our energy security can no longer be centrally controlled, we now require new security frameworks to inform and incentivise best practice across an increasingly decentralised, disparate value chain. 

The Need For A Holistic Security Framework

Without direct control over energy security, grid operators must use cyber security frameworks to assess business risk across all cyber, digital and data projects and enforce best practice among all partners and suppliers. These frameworks should be based on best-practice standards such as IEC 62443.

Cyber security should be baked into procurement and partnership programmes from the outset so that all potential suppliers and partners are carefully vetted for compliance with security standards. Imposing cyber frameworks on Tier 1 suppliers would create a cascade of best practice cyber security as each tier of suppliers enforces the same standards on lower tiers. 

New digital or data projects should not be introduced in silos without considering their potential impact on risk across the organisation. All digital, data and cyber projects should instead be interconnected from the start so that security is baked in at design stage and risks can be continuously assessed as new technologies are added. For example, reports found that some electricity generation is vulnerable to ransomware attacks because of clean energy infrastructure that was designed without security in mind. Cyber risk assessments cannot be a one-off exercise at implementation stage but must be monitored and managed across the lifecycle of all energy assets. 

Rather than focusing narrowly on cyber risks, organisations should also get an integrated overview of business risk across all digital and data projects so that diverse digital ecosystems can be monitored and managed as a single ‘system of systems’. 

Organisations also need to manage all third-party remote monitoring and maintenance of energy infrastructure with strict user permissions to validate and verify user identities before granting access to energy networks. Any service providers with responsibility for energy data or remote access to infrastructure must be strictly vetted against a checklist of criteria.

The widening array of edge devices from mobile apps to smart meters opening new vulnerabilities to energy systems requires that all suppliers are thoroughly vetted to ensure they conduct continuous monitoring and patching of devices throughout their lifecycle.  

Steven O’Sullivan is Head of Smart Cybersecurity at Enzen 

You Might Also Read:

Process Sensor Cyber Security Is A Vital Issue:

 

« How To Improve Cyber Security Visibility & Control
Georgia Must Bolster Resilience To Information Warfare »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

IT Governance

IT Governance

IT Governance is a leading global provider of information security solutions. Download our free guide and find out how ISO 27001 can help protect your organisation's information.

LockLizard

LockLizard

Locklizard provides PDF DRM software that protects PDF documents from unauthorized access and misuse. Share and sell documents securely - prevent document leakage, sharing and piracy.

ON-DEMAND WEBINAR: How to improve your security posture with a web application firewall (WAF)

ON-DEMAND WEBINAR: How to improve your security posture with a web application firewall (WAF)

Watch this webinar to discover how a WAF goes beyond a standard firewall and helps you meet security industry compliance.

Authentic8

Authentic8

Authentic8 transforms how organizations secure and control the use of the web with Silo, its patented cloud browser.

CYRIN

CYRIN

CYRIN® Cyber Range. Real Tools, Real Attacks, Real Scenarios. See why leading educational institutions and companies in the U.S. have begun to adopt the CYRIN® system.

E-core

E-core

e-Core offers the highest quality standards in offsite software development, quality assurance, and application support services

CyberSecurityJobsite.com

CyberSecurityJobsite.com

CyberSecurityJobsite.com is a specialist job board designed to attract candidates working within Cyber Security, Information Security or Information Assurance.

Cyber Security National Lab (CINI)

Cyber Security National Lab (CINI)

The Cyber Security National Lab brings together Italian academic excellence in Cyber Security research.

Networkers

Networkers

Networkers is a global recruitment consultancy helping unite job-seekers and hiring companies across the technology industry.

CyberNB

CyberNB

Canada's epicentre for cybersecurity. CyberNB is focused on cyber skills and workforce development, R&D, protecting our critical infrastructure, innovation and building a world class cyber ecosystem.

PrivateVPN

PrivateVPN

PrivateVPN is a Virtual Private Network services provider offering secure encrypted access to the internet.

Cyber Security Raad (CSR) - Netherlands

Cyber Security Raad (CSR) - Netherlands

The Cyber Security Council (CSR) is a national, independent advisory body of the Dutch government undertaking efforts at strategic level to bolster cyber security in the Netherlands.

ThreadStone Cyber Security

ThreadStone Cyber Security

ThreadStone Cyber Security offer reliable, practical and affordable cyber security solutions for both large and smaller organizations that we develop and deliver ourselves from Europe.

Sixgill

Sixgill

Sixgill, an IoT sensor platform company, builds the universal data service and smart process automation software allowing any organization to effectively govern its IoE assets.

Angoka

Angoka

Angoka provide hardware-based solutions for managing the cybersecurity risks inherent in machine-to-machine communication networks.

DataViper

DataViper

Data viper is a threat intelligence platform designed for organizations, investigators, and law enforcement.

IntelliGenesis

IntelliGenesis

IntelliGenesis provide comprehensive cyber, data science, analysis, and software development services that provide tailored, secure solutions for your critical data and intelligence needs.

INVISUS

INVISUS

INVISUS protects businesses against the latest cyber risks – including business and employee identity theft, data breaches, and cybersecurity compliance.

Stone Forest IT (SFIT)

Stone Forest IT (SFIT)

Stone Forest IT specialises in providing advisory, implementation and managed services for IT infrastructure, IT security solutions, business applications (ERP and CRM) and business analytical tools.

Ward Solutions

Ward Solutions

Ward Solutions are an information security consultancy and managed services company. We help organisations protect their brand, people, assets, intellectual property and profits.

Think|Stack

Think|Stack

Think|Stack is a managed IT services company specializing in cloud and cybersecurity with human-centered design.