GCHQ Data Collection Violated Rights To Privacy

A mass surveillance programme by the UK government violated human rights, the European Court has ruled. It comes some-time after US whistleblower Edward Snowden disclosed British surveillance and intelligence-sharing practices. 

GCHQ’s methods in carrying out bulk interception of online communications violated privacy and failed to provide sufficient surveillance safeguards, the European court of human rights (ECHR) has ruled in a test case judgment.

But the Strasbourg court found that GCHQ’s regime for sharing sensitive digital intelligence with foreign governments was not illegal.

The judges considered three aspects of digital surveillance: bulk interception of communications, intelligence sharing and obtaining of communications data from communications service providers.

By a majority of five to two votes, the Strasbourg judges found that GCHQ’s bulk interception regime violated article 8 of the European convention on human rights, which guarantees privacy, because there were said to be insufficient safeguards, and rules governing the selection of “related communications data” were deemed to be inadequate.

The regime for sharing intelligence with foreign governments operated by the UK government did not, however, violate either article 8 or article 10.

It is the first major challenge to the legality of UK intelligence agencies intercepting private communications in bulk, following Edward Snowden’s whistleblowing revelations.

The long-awaited ruling is one of the most comprehensive assessments by the ECHR of the legality of the interception operations operated by UK intelligence agencies.

In a landmark case brought by charities including Amnesty and human rights group Big Brother Watch, the top court ruled that the "bulk interception regime" breached rights to privacy (Article 8).

The legal challenge was triggered by revelations made by Snowden in 2013, which showed GCHQ, the UK’s Government Communications Headquarters, was secretly intercepting, processing and storing data about millions of people’s private communications, even when those people were of no intelligence interest. In one of the operations, called Tempora, GCHQ was tapping into cables and communication networks to obtain huge volumes of internet data.
Snowden praised the judgment saying that governments had been pursued through the courts for five years. “Today, we won,” he said.

The former CIA employee had revealed that security services had been collecting bulk data, including telephone calls, messages and internet communication, whether or not people were suspected of a crime.
The case centred on powers given to security services under the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000 (Ripa), which has since been replaced.

In their ruling, judges declared there was insufficient monitoring of what information was being collected and that some safeguards were "inadequate".

They also found the programme breached rights to freedom of expression (Article 10) "as there were insufficient safeguards in respect of confidential journalistic material".

They wrote: "In view of the potential chilling effect that any perceived interference with the confidentiality of journalists' communications and, in particular, their sources might have on the freedom of the press, the Court found that the bulk interception regime was also in violation of article 10."

There was also not enough protection to ensure the safety of confidential journalistic sources, the judges ruled.
Three applications were joined together, from Big Brother Watch, the Bureau of Investigative Journalism, and 10 human rights charities, and were lodged after Mr Snowden's revelations.

All applicants felt their line of work meant they were more subject to having their communications intercepted by intelligence services.

The complaints centred on articles 8 and 10 of the convention of human rights, which protect a right to a private family life, and freedom of expression, with applicants saying bulk interception breached both.
The court did rule that a bulk operation on its own does not break the convention, but said that such a regime "had to respect criteria set down in its case law".

Because there was not enough independent oversight of the search and selection processes, there was a violation of the code. Judges on the case did not agree with the applicants over issues of sharing the information with foreign governments, ruling there was no evidence of abuse or significant shortcomings.

Sky:

You Might Also Read:

Cyberspies: The Secret History of Surveillance, Hacking And Digital Espionage:

Snowden Says Social Media Is Surveillance 'Rebranded':

 

« Enterprise Blockchain Struggles To Carve Out A Niche
How Hackers Skipped Through BA’s Security »

ManageEngine
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Check Point

Directory of Suppliers

NordLayer

NordLayer

NordLayer is an adaptive network access security solution for modern businesses — from the world’s most trusted cybersecurity brand, Nord Security. 

CSI Consulting Services

CSI Consulting Services

Get Advice From The Experts: * Training * Penetration Testing * Data Governance * GDPR Compliance. Connecting you to the best in the business.

CYRIN

CYRIN

CYRIN® Cyber Range. Real Tools, Real Attacks, Real Scenarios. See why leading educational institutions and companies in the U.S. have begun to adopt the CYRIN® system.

Lunar

Lunar

Lunar is a free, enterprise-grade, compromised-credentials monitoring platform, available to every company, everywhere.

Clayden Law

Clayden Law

Clayden Law advise global businesses that buy and sell technology products and services. We are experts in information technology, data privacy and cybersecurity law.

Integrity360

Integrity360

Integrity360 is a leading independent cyber security and payments compliance specialist providing dedicated experts for managed services, consulting services, penetration testing and incident response

Cybernetic Global Intelligence (CGI)

Cybernetic Global Intelligence (CGI)

CGI is a global IT Security firm that helps companies protect their data and minimize their vulnerability to cyber threats through a range of services such as Security Audits and Managed Services.

Cyacomb

Cyacomb

Cyacomb (formerly Cyan Forensics) provides digital forensics software to help police forces find evidence on computers many times faster than before.

AimBrain

AimBrain

AimBrain tools detect and prevent fraud, faster and more accurately than ever before.

FraudHunt

FraudHunt

FraudHunt protects your website from account fraud, ad fraud, fraud clicks, and malicious bots.

RIA in a Box

RIA in a Box

MyRIACompliance combines our team of RIA compliance experts with an online software platform to help investment advisers better manage regulatory compliance and cybersecurity responsibilities.

iSecurity Consulting

iSecurity Consulting

iSecurity delivers a complete lifecycle of digital protection services across the globe for public and private sector clients.

DataViper

DataViper

DataViper is a threat intelligence platform designed for organizations, investigators, and law enforcement.

BIO-key

BIO-key

BIO-key is a pioneer and innovator, we are recognized as a leading developer of fingerprint biometric authentication and security solutions.

NOW Insurance

NOW Insurance

NOW Insurance provides small business owners and other professional classes with a seamless purchasing experience for general liability, professional liability, and cybersecurity insurance coverage.

Dataships

Dataships

We help companies automate their privacy compliance while building healthy, transparent data relationships with their customers.

AirDroid Business

AirDroid Business

AirDroid Business is an efficient mobile device management solution for Android devices, helping businesses to remotely control and access devices in large quantities using a centralized approach.

Dutch Research Council (NWO)

Dutch Research Council (NWO)

The Dutch Research Council (NWO) is one of the most important science-funding bodies in the Netherlands and ensures quality and innovation in science.

Cyberhill Partners

Cyberhill Partners

Cyberhill is a professional engineering services firm solving complex software implementation and integration challenges.

MineOS

MineOS

MineOS aligns compliance with business growth. We designed our platform so that privacy compliance efforts directly benefit other teams and initiatives.

DuploCloud

DuploCloud

DuploCloud offers an end-to-end DevOps software platform for dev teams that don’t have dedicated DevOps engineers and augments those that do.