Lawyers Beware: A Robot Will Take Your Job

Well-tuned search engines could save junior legal professionals a lot of time and suffering. But where does human intelligence come in?

Venture-capital firm Invoke Capital just made a multi-million-dollar investment in Luminance, which is developing artificial intelligence to automate the legal drudgery involved in corporate mergers and acquisitions. The robot lawyer is just one of many, including offerings from Ross Intelligence and Kira Systems, aiming to replace the overworked factotums known as associate attorneys. 

According to Bloomberg, Invoke founder Mike Lynch said that Luminance can "read natural language and actually understand it, using it to categorize documents, rather than just searching text to match key words or standard clauses.”

However what he seems to be describing is the exact function of a search engine. Due diligence, the process Luminance is supposed to automate, essentially involves organizing massive piles of legal documents into smaller piles based on their relevance, the specialty domain of search engines. Even the IBM-Watson technology that powers Ross is, for the most part, a search engine.

The fact that their software isn’t quite so unique, though, doesn’t detract from robot lawyers' potential. What really matters for their “intelligence” is the data on which they are trained. Ross focuses the Watson technology, which won "Jeopardy!" in 2011, on court filings instead of the full text of Wikipedia. To prepare for its specialty of contract review, Luminance has studied "thousands of documents and contract clauses.”

Well-tuned search engines could save people a lot of time and suffering. Luminance promises to increase the efficiency of contract review by at least 50 percent. Kira Systems claims a time reduction of as much as 90 percent. If Bayer’s legal team had included robot lawyers, maybe they could have completed due diligence for the Monsanto deal in days.

So will the associate attorney, among the least satisfying jobs in the US, become a thing of the past? Not necessarily. Even though automated-review tools are great for organizing documents into actionable information, intelligent humans are required to step in when the computer encounters ambiguous language or unexpected cases. It’s like how self-driving cars still have human supervisors in the vehicle to deal with rogue squirrels or trolley problems.

That said, the need for humans will diminish. As machines process more data, previously ambiguous information will become recognizable. Consider tax returns. Thanks to the US Internal Revenue Service's automated computer review system, trained on hundreds of millions of returns annually, humans need to show up only in the event of an audit, which happens in less than 1 percent of cases. It’s just a matter of time before Luminance develops similarly powerful pattern recognition.

The main difference between a junior associate and a partner at a major law firmis the sheer quantity of data that the person has seen. A computer can process data much faster, with far more accurate recall ability. Once a robot learns to structure merger agreements and negotiate corporate acquisition deals, human-readable legal documents will be little more than an afterthought.

Eventually, human lawyers will be called in to interpret only the rare ambiguity, likely a human-generated flaw that never would have existed if lawyers had used robots in the first place.

Information-Management
 

« The Dilemma Of Predictive Policing
A New Front In The Business Of Political Espionage »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

Practice Labs

Practice Labs

Practice Labs is an IT competency hub, where live-lab environments give access to real equipment for hands-on practice of essential cybersecurity skills.

ON-DEMAND WEBINAR: What Is A Next-Generation Firewall And Why Does It Matter

ON-DEMAND WEBINAR: What Is A Next-Generation Firewall And Why Does It Matter

See how to use next-generation firewalls (NGFWs) and how they boost your security posture.

BackupVault

BackupVault

BackupVault is a leading provider of automatic cloud backup and critical data protection against ransomware, insider attacks and hackers for businesses and organisations worldwide.

Jooble

Jooble

Jooble is a job search aggregator operating in 71 countries worldwide. We simplify the job search process by displaying active job ads from major job boards and career sites across the internet.

IT Governance

IT Governance

IT Governance is a leading global provider of information security solutions. Download our free guide and find out how ISO 27001 can help protect your organisation's information.

Conference-Service.com

Conference-Service.com

Conference-Service.com provides a categorised calendar of conferences and events which includes Information Security.

Critifence

Critifence

Critifence provides unique Cyber Security solutions designed for Critical Infrastructure, SCADA and Industrial Control Systems.

Ipsidy

Ipsidy

Our identity platform enables mobile users to more easily authenticate their identity to a mobile phone or portable device of their choosing.

Torsion Information Security

Torsion Information Security

Torsion is an innovative information security and compliance engine, which runs either in the cloud or your data centre.

Cybertech

Cybertech

Cybertech Conference & Exhibition presents commercial problem solving strategies and solutions for the global cyber threat that meet the diverse challenges for a wide range of sectors.

Security Innovation Network (SINET)

Security Innovation Network (SINET)

SINET is dedicated to building a cohesive, worldwide Cybersecurity community with the goal of accelerating innovation through collaboration.

Cryptika

Cryptika

Cryptika is a fully integrated IT security and managed services provider, specialized in Next-Generation Cyber Security Technologies.

Unit21

Unit21

Unit21 helps protect businesses against adversaries through a simple API and dashboard for detecting and managing money laundering, fraud, and other sophisticated risks across multiple industries.

Defentry

Defentry

Defentry have created an Ecosystem that lets our users easily monitor, train and resolve their digital security issues.

Oman Technology Fund (OTF)

Oman Technology Fund (OTF)

Oman Technology Fund aims to make Oman the preferred destination for emerging tech companies in the region, and an attractive and stimulating destination for venture capital.

Singtel Innov8

Singtel Innov8

Singtel Innov8, the venture capital arm of the Singtel Group, invests in and partners with innovative technology start-ups globally.

InfoSec Brigade

InfoSec Brigade

InfoSec Brigade offers a suite of specialized solutions that help businesses to mitigate risk by integrating cyber and IT security protocols with business goals.

PolySwarm

PolySwarm

PolySwarm is a crowdsourced threat intelligence marketplace that provides a more effective way to detect, analyze and respond to the latest threats.

SoftForum

SoftForum

SoftForum is a company specializing in next-generation information security solutions in the Quantum-Resistant-Cryptography (PQC) field.

Safe Decision

Safe Decision

Safe Decision is an information technology company offering Cyber Security, Network, and Infrastructure Services and Solutions.

VP Techno Labs

VP Techno Labs

VP Techno Labs is an award-winning cybersecurity firm focusing only cybersecurity to develop cutting edge solutions for emerging business.