Meta Faces Landmark Child Safety Trial

Meta is being sued in California by 29 US states for deceiving consumers and violating federal child protection laws by exposing young users to violent or sexual content and addiction risks. The US court has heard claims Meta intentionally captured a generation of children on Facebook and Instagram, as the biggest legal challenge faced by the social media platform began.

It is the biggest trial of its kind yet, with dozens of states seeking financial damages that could total as much as $1.4 trillion (£1.03 trillion ). A jury in Oakland, California will spend weeks considering competing  claims by top attorneys from several US states and lawyers for the social media company.

A lawyer for California claimed Meta found millions of 11 and 12-year-olds were on Instagram and did little to keep them off as the trial opened on Tuesday. Meta's representative said just over 100,000 such users were found, and argued that social media addiction does not exist. California's lawyer said Meta knew its platforms hurt teen mental health, while Meta said it was being ignored how many more teens had good experiences.

Origins of the Multistate Lawsuit

The trial stems from a lawsuit filed in 2023 by 29 US states, including California and New York. They claim there have been numerous violations of federal and state privacy laws for children. In her opening arguments Megan O'Neill, a lead attorney for California, relied heavily on information found in millions of documents provided in the case from Meta. They included internal research, employee emails, and chat logs that went all the way up to Zuckerberg.

Evidence From Internal Meta Research

One piece of internal research on Instagram stated: Teens have an addict's narrative about use. In another that O'Neill pointed the jury to, Meta found product features designed to increase time spent are inherently at odds with well-being and take away from people's ability to focus on activity that adds value to their lives. Despite Meta's awareness of potentially negative impacts, O'Neill argued that Meta targeted young people as users of Facebook and Instagram. Meta, she said, went out of its way to assure the public that its platforms were safe for kids.

O'Neill outlined to the jury how Meta's business model could be summed up. Hook the users; hold them for as long as they can; harvest their data; hide the truth from the public when making public statements, she said.

Meta's Response to the Allegations

The attorney for Meta, Paul Schmidt, directly addressed the internal research report O'Neill used in her opening arguments. The Meta document O'Neill showed the jury found that 1 in 5 teens says Instagram makes them feel worse.

Schmidt said: that sounds pretty bad. What else does the document say? Schmidt went on. That 41 percent of teens said it made them feel better and another 41 percent said it had no effect.

Schmidt aimed to show up problems in the states' case, in particular, the argument that Meta had not only failed to stop users under the age of 13 from using its platforms, but that it intentionally exploited teens and children as users of Facebook and Instagram, or that they were designed to be addictive. As for Meta being able to verify the age of every user on its platform, Schmidt argued that the very privacy laws Meta was being accused of violating had prevented it from saving and using data it needed to track underage users effectively.

Schmidt also argued a point that Meta has put forward in other litigation this year - that social media addiction simply does not exist.

There can be no dispute that Meta has recognised people struggle, or can struggle, with their use of social media, and has come up with tools to try and address that, Schmidt said, asserting that there is no research availalble that shows an addiction to social media is possible. 

Schmidt pointed to past statements from chief executive Mark Zuckerberg and head of Instagram Adam Mosseri in which they said Facebook and Instagram were not designed to be addictive. 

The case continues and is expected to go on for another four to six weeks. 

Le Monde  |   BBC  |  BBC   |  Sky  |  Guardian  |  CNN   

Image:  Nick Fancher

You Might Also Read: 

Facebook & Instagram Remove Fact Checkers:


If you like this website and use the comprehensive 8,000-plus service supplier Directory, you can get unrestricted access, including the exclusive in-depth Directors Report series, by signing up for a Premium Subscription.

  • Individual £5 per month or £50 per year. Sign Up
  • Multi-User, Corporate & Library Accounts Available on Request

Cyber Security Intelligence: Captured Organised & Accessible


 

« Brazilian Police Swoop In Global Bank Fraud
Iranian Hackers Shut Down British Power Plant »

ManageEngine
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Check Point

Directory of Suppliers

CSI Consulting Services

CSI Consulting Services

Get Advice From The Experts: * Training * Penetration Testing * Data Governance * GDPR Compliance. Connecting you to the best in the business.

Clayden Law

Clayden Law

Clayden Law advise global businesses that buy and sell technology products and services. We are experts in information technology, data privacy and cybersecurity law.

CYRIN

CYRIN

CYRIN® Cyber Range. Real Tools, Real Attacks, Real Scenarios. See why leading educational institutions and companies in the U.S. have begun to adopt the CYRIN® system.

International Association of Professional Security Consultants (IAPSC)

International Association of Professional Security Consultants (IAPSC)

Members of the IAPSC represent a unique group of respected, ethical and competent security consultants.

Digital Detective

Digital Detective

Digital Detective offer a range of products and services for digital forensic analysis and advanced data recovery.

Arcanum Information Security (AIS)

Arcanum Information Security (AIS)

Arcanum Information Security is a specialist Information Assurance Consultancy and a leading provider of Cyber Security services to UK Defence, UK Government, Enterprise businesses and SMEs.

mPrest

mPrest

mPrest is a global provider of mission-critical monitoring and control solutions for the defense, security, utility and Industrial Internet of Things (IoT) sectors.

ToucanX

ToucanX

ToucanX has eliminated remote attack vectors without sacrificing productivity. We’ve brought embedded near real time virtualization to the enterprise endpoint.

Stealth-ISS Group

Stealth-ISS Group

Stealth–ISS Group is your extended IT, cyber security, risk and compliance team, providing strategic guidance, engineering and audit services, along with technical remediation and security operations.

IntelliGenesis

IntelliGenesis

IntelliGenesis provide comprehensive cyber, data science, analysis, and software development services that provide tailored, secure solutions for your critical data and intelligence needs.

CyberHunter Solutions

CyberHunter Solutions

CyberHunter is a leading website security company that provides penetration testing, Network Vulnerability Assessments, cyber security consulting services to prevent cyber attacks.

Condition Zebra

Condition Zebra

Condition Zebra has wide experience in providing IT Security Services, Training, and Certification in the field of cybersecurity.

Bosch Global Software Technologies (BGSW)

Bosch Global Software Technologies (BGSW)

Bosch Global Software Technologies offer an advanced innovation for AI security. The Bosch AIShield is the definite answer to safeguard your business against model extraction attacks.

CloudScale365

CloudScale365

CloudScale365 offers state-of-the-art managed IT services and cloud, hosting, security, and business continuity solutions.

Resilience Cyber insurance

Resilience Cyber insurance

Resilience helps to improve cyber resilience by connecting cyber insurance coverage with advanced cybersecurity visibility and a shared plan to reinforce great cyber hygiene.

Oort

Oort

Oort is an identity threat detection and response platform for enterprise security. The Oort platform is API-driven, cloud-native and agentless for rapid time to value and high scalability.

Protos Labs

Protos Labs

Protos Labs enables insurers & enterprises to make better cyber risk decisions through holistic, real-time risk management tools.

Offenso Hackers Academy

Offenso Hackers Academy

At Offenso we focus on cyber security training focused on producing cyber security professionals with a wide range of abilities to counter threats from the internet and cloud to a business.

ITButler e-Services

ITButler e-Services

Why should you choose IT Butler as your Managed Security Service Partner?

OVUL Security

OVUL Security

OVUL goes beyond basic security scanning with advanced threat detection and real-time monitoring.

pQCee

pQCee

pQCee are in the business of designing and building post-quantum products and services to strengthen and protect the next generation of computing against quantum attacks.