Negotiating Ransom: To Pay Or Not?

Ransomware is one of the key cyber security threats that faces business and the cyber criminals behind it are becoming more dangerousOver the past eighteen months there has been a surge of ransomware attacks, made more disruptive by the complications of Coronavirus.  

From the criminals’ point of view, ransomware is massively profitable and a relatively easy exploit to accomplish. According to the European Union Agency for Cybersecurity (ENISA) 45 percent of victim organisations pay the ransom.

In December 2020, the acting head of the US Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) said that ransomware was “quickly becoming a national emergency,” and it now effects most countries and corporates. In Britain, Lindy Cameron, newly appointed the chief of the British National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC) says her agency is committed to tackling the threat of ransomware and "supports victims of ransomware every day" but that a coordinated response is required to combat the growing threat. 

Speaking earlier this month, Lindy Cameron said "For the vast majority of UK citizens and businesses, and indeed for the vast majority of critical national infrastructure providers and government service providers, the primary key threat is not state actors but cyber criminals." She also noted that the ecosystem is evolving through the Ransomware as a Service (RaaS) model, whereby ransomware variants and commodity listings are available off the shelf for a one-off payment or a share of the profits.

Many analysts were surprised at how quickly the attack victim paid the $4.4 million ransom demanded when the US Colonial Pipeline was struck with ransomware recently, although much of the money extorted has since been recovered by the FBI.

The Colonial Pipeline CEO Joseph Blount told US lawmakers that although his company had an emergency-response plan in place, it didn’t include plans for responding to a ransomware attack.  However, the company did have insurance to pay for ransomware attacks, so the decision to pay was swift. A ransomware notice first appeared on a machine in Colonial Pipeline’s control room around 5 a.m. on May 7th and by 6 a.m. the company had shut down its 5,000-mile pipeline, Blount testified. 

By 7 a.m. the company had contacted outside legal counsel and engaged digital investigations firm FireEye to begin a forensic assessment of the damage. By late afternoon the same day, Blount decided to pay the ransom and on May 8th the money was sent.

The FBI advises victims to avoid negotiating with hackers, arguing that paying ransoms incentivises criminal behavior. This puts victims in a tricky position. “Regardless of whether you or your organisation have decided to pay the ransom, the FBI urges you to report ransomware incidents to law enforcement. Doing so provides investigators with the critical information they need to track ransomware attackers, hold them accountable under US law, and prevent future attacks”, says an FBI report.

The rise in ransomware as a business for criminals has produced a parallel rise in companies engaged in helping victims negotiate ransoms and recover the money extorted. 

Negotiating ransoms is a fraught process that can take more than a week and change rapidly, depending on the demands of the extortionists and the condition of the victim’s backups, according to Bill Siegel, CEO and co-founder of Coveware, a company that negotiates ransomware payments for victims. Coveware also aggregates statistics and other data about ransomware incidents to help the government track the scourge. Siegel told The New Yorker that Coveware has negotiated a “few thousand” ransomware cases since 2018 and that each case is different..

Siegel declined to discuss his customers or the specifics of negotiations, to avoid giving ransomware actors insight into negotiating tactics. Handling one of these negotiations is not easy and often goes five or seven days, it typically means that the company isn’t sure if they actually need to pay or not.

If an organisation has to pay very fast, it’s typically because they know they have no other means to recover.

The issue for most organisations is that they have not properly configured a backup if they suffer a ransomware attack. A server that gets impacted with ransomware has to be, at a minimum, heavily remediated to ever be trusted again. The best practice is to establish a clean backup network where you can re-image all of the servers, re-install all of the applications and then, for the data,  upload uncontaminated backups that you can restore to the backup network servers. To determine if files will decrypt properly you need to do scans on all of the encrypted files to look at the integrity of the encryption. A properly encrypted file will normally properly decrypt. 

A major aspect of the he Colonial Pipeline outage is that it had cascading effects that the company had no direct control over - the reaction of consumers - who started panic-buying and hoarding fuel.  Even though there wasn’t actually a fuel shortage, people created a fuel shortage from panic.

This is a compelling example of the follow-on effects that might not anticipated in an emergency and which that can put pressure on organisations to pay the ransom.

NCSC:    FBI:     Zero Day:    New Yorker:     ENISA:     SHRM:    ZDNet:   CloudsavvyIT:     Schnier On Security:

Image: Unsplash

You Might Also Read:

Running Out Of Cyber Gas

Will Governments Ban Ransom Payments To Hackers?:

 

 

« DarkSide May Not Stay Dark For Long
Global Police Operation Closes Fake Pharma Websites »

ManageEngine
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Check Point

Directory of Suppliers

TÜV SÜD Academy UK

TÜV SÜD Academy UK

TÜV SÜD offers expert-led cybersecurity training to help organisations safeguard their operations and data.

MIRACL

MIRACL

MIRACL provides the world’s only single step Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) which can replace passwords on 100% of mobiles, desktops or even Smart TVs.

CYRIN

CYRIN

CYRIN® Cyber Range. Real Tools, Real Attacks, Real Scenarios. See why leading educational institutions and companies in the U.S. have begun to adopt the CYRIN® system.

Directory of Cyber Security Suppliers

Directory of Cyber Security Suppliers

Our Supplier Directory lists 8,000+ specialist cyber security service providers in 128 countries worldwide. IS YOUR ORGANISATION LISTED?

Resecurity

Resecurity

Resecurity is a cybersecurity company that delivers a unified platform for endpoint protection, risk management, and cyber threat intelligence.

Fasoo

Fasoo

Fasoo provides data-centric security to protect data within the organizational perimeter and beyond by limiting access to sensitive data according to policies that cover both users and activities.

CERT-UA

CERT-UA

CERT-UA is the national Computer Emergency Response Team for Ukraine.

BaseN

BaseN

BaseN is a full stack IoT Operator. We control the full value chain in order to provide ultimate scalability, fault tolerance and security to our customers.

Pixalate

Pixalate

Pixalate is an omni-channel fraud intelligence company that works with brands and platforms to prevent invalid traffic and improve ad inventory quality.

Pentest People

Pentest People

Pentest People are a UK-based security consultancy focussing on bringing the benefits of Pentesting as a Service (PTaaS) to all its clients.

Cloud GRC

Cloud GRC

Cloud GRC is an innovative cybersecurity company with solutions and expertise in Cybersecurity Strategies & Frameworks, Threat & Risk Assessment, Cloud Security, and Regulatory Compliance Requirements

Blackbird.AI

Blackbird.AI

Blackbird.AI provides an intelligence and early-warning system to help users detect disinformation and take action against threats.

Intechtel

Intechtel

Intechtel is a cyber security company, in addition to providing other internet, technology and telephone services.

Earlybird Venture Capital

Earlybird Venture Capital

Earlybird is a venture capital investor focused on European technology innovators.

Probity

Probity

Probity Inc. is a certified software development and systems engineering company, providing support to federal government and national defense related clients.

Hook Security

Hook Security

Setting a new standard in security awareness. Hook Security is a people-first company that uses psychological security training to help companies create security-aware culture.

SafeAeon

SafeAeon

SafeAeon is a leading Cybersecurity-as-a-Service provider, offering 24x7 premium Managed Security Services with AI-powered and Human-driven 24x7 SOC.

Forthright Technology Partners

Forthright Technology Partners

Forthright Technology Partners (Forthright) is a next-generation cloud and managed IT services provider serving a global clientele.

Grey Market Labs

Grey Market Labs

Grey Market Labs is a special place. It is a data privacy and security skunkworks.

Memgraph

Memgraph

Memgraph, is an in-memory graph database designed for real-time applications such as risk assessment, 360-degree data and network data exploration, and supply chain and network logistics.

Pellera Technologies

Pellera Technologies

Pellera Technologies is by a singular purpose: to empower organizations with innovative IT solutions that unlock potential, drive progress, and fuel transformation.