Predicting Crime From Open Source Data

A new crime prediction technology has been creating controversy. Brett Goldstein, an ex-cop, founded CivicScape, a technology company that sells crime-predicting software to police departments.

Nine US cities are either using the software or in the process of implementing it, including four of the US’s 35 largest cities by population.

The criminal justice system produces reams of data, and new computing methods offer to turn any pool of numbers into something useful. Today, almost every major police department is using or has used some form of commercial software that makes predictions about crime, either to determine what blocks warrant heightened police presence or even which people are most likely to be involved. Technology is transforming the craft of policing.

Not everyone is rubbing their hands in anticipation. Many police officers still see so-called predictive policing software as mumbo jumbo. Critics outside of law enforcement argue that it’s actively destructive. The historical information these programs use to predict patterns of crime aren’t a neutral recounting of objective fact; they’re a reflection of socioeconomic disparities and the aggressive policing of black neighborhoods. Computer scientists have held up predictive policing as a poster child of a how automated decision making can be misused.

“Systems that manufacture unexplained ‘threat’ assessments have no valid place in constitutional policing,” wrote a coalition of civil rights and technology associations in a statement last summer. A numbing progression of police shootings in the past several years serve as a reminder of what’s at stake when police officers see certain communities as disproportionately threatening.

Over the course of eight days in late June, juries failed to convict officers who killed black men in Minnesota, Ohio, and Wisconsin. In each case, the officer’s defense relied on his perception of danger. The worst-case scenario with predictive policing software is deploying officers to target areas with their ears raised, leading them to turn violent in what would otherwise be routine encounters.

Goldstein’s company published its code on GitHub In March, a website where computer programmers post and critique one another’s work. It was an unprecedented move, given the usual secrecy of the industry and it caused an immediate stir among people who follow the cop tech industry.
 
The Camden County Police Department’s Real-Time Tactical Operation Intelligence Center (RT-TOIC) is a great test on how you feel about tech in law enforcement. The RT-TOIC, is a windowless room from which the department runs its technological initiatives. Camden integrated CivicScape into the RT-TOIC three months ago.

The company’s maps are always running, changing every hour to reflect updated data. When targets change, analysts switch their screens to the surveillance cameras pointed at those blocks. Officers translate what’s happening in the RT-TOIC to the cops on the street. The guys in patrol cars don’t know whether an order is derived from some newfangled math, the judgment of a superior officer, or a mixture. The ambiguity is deliberate, said Kerry Yerico, the department’s director of criminal intelligence and analysis.

Unlike an algorithm in which a human has consciously told the system what to think about each factor, neural networks find their own paths and can’t effectively explain to humans what they’ve done. This has the potential to make CivicScape even less transparent than other predictive policing software, which use different types of algorithms.

Scott Thompson, Camden’s police chief, said he hasn’t heard any criticism about transparency. For its part, CivicScape said its openness comes from inviting discussion about the types of data its models use. The company decided against using arrests for marijuana possession at all, for instance, given widespread research showing racial disparities in these arrests.

Kristian Lum and William Isaac, researchers who have written their own statistical models for the Human Rights Data Analysis Group demonstrating how bias works in predictive policing, have examined the code. They both described CivicScape’s move as positive but withheld praise until they see how the company followed through.

I-HLS:

You Might Also Read: 

AI And Robotics Can Fight Cyber Crime:

Can We Stop Algorithms Telling Lies?:

FBI’s Cybercrime Report 2017:

« Can We Stop Algorithms Telling Lies?
Australia Wants Technology Businesses To Act On Extremism »

ManageEngine
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Check Point

Directory of Suppliers

ZenGRC

ZenGRC

ZenGRC (formerly Reciprocity) is a leader in the GRC SaaS landscape, offering robust and intuitive products designed to make compliance straightforward and efficient.

Clayden Law

Clayden Law

Clayden Law advise global businesses that buy and sell technology products and services. We are experts in information technology, data privacy and cybersecurity law.

Keygraph

Keygraph

Keygraph builds AI penetration testing for application security teams. Keygraph also builds Shannon, a leading open-source AI pentester

CSI Consulting Services

CSI Consulting Services

Get Advice From The Experts: * Training * Penetration Testing * Data Governance * GDPR Compliance. Connecting you to the best in the business.

ManageEngine

ManageEngine

As the IT management division of Zoho Corporation, ManageEngine prioritizes flexible solutions that work for all businesses, regardless of size or budget.

Versasec

Versasec

Versasec is a leader in identity and access management, providing customers with security solutions for managing digital identities.

Arista Networks

Arista Networks

Arista Networks is an industry leader in data-driven, client to cloud networking for large data center, campus and routing environments.

CERT.BY

CERT.BY

The National Computer Emergency Response Team of the Republic of Belarus.

Thales

Thales

Thales provides solutions, services and products that help its customers in the defence, aeronautics, space, transportation and digital identity and security markets to fulfil their critical missions.

Open Systems International (OSI)

Open Systems International (OSI)

Our innovative Operations Technology (OT) solutions are highly scalable and can be deployed by various utility companies to monitor, control and optimize their real-time operations.

DefCamp

DefCamp

DefCamp is the most important annual conference on Hacking & Information Security in Central Eastern Europe.

360° Online Brand Protection

360° Online Brand Protection

360° Online Brand Protection have developed a response to monitor counterfeiting and piracy activity at the online point of sale.

Beyond Identity

Beyond Identity

Beyond Identity employs an elegantly simple concept, the personal certificate authority and self signed certificates, to replace passwords.

Ridge Global

Ridge Global

Ridge Global works with C-suite executives and corporate directors to build more resilient organizations through innovative preparedness, protection, response and education capabilities.

ITSEC Asia

ITSEC Asia

ITSEC Asia works to effectively reduce exposure to information security threats and improve the effectiveness of its clients' information security management systems.

Evolver

Evolver

Evolver delivers technology services and solutions that improve security, promote innovation, and maximize operational efficiency in support of government and commercial customers.

Verastel

Verastel

Specializing in the niche space of proactive cyber-defense, and adaptive resilience, team Verastel is bolstering enterprise digital security like never before.

B&L PC Solutions

B&L PC Solutions

B&L PC Solutions deliver top cyber security services on Long Island and New York city to protect businesses from evolving online threats.

Empirical Security

Empirical Security

Empirical builds mathematical models for security data. We maintain the world’s most advanced global models for cybersecurity, and we build local models that respond to your specific context.

Theodosian

Theodosian

Theodosian is a developer of file-level data protection software designed for secure information governance.

Trustfull

Trustfull

Trustfull was created to empower businesses with cutting-edge, OSINT-based fraud prevention solutions to build trust globally.