Robots Will Invade The Workplace

Marc Andreessen, venture capitalist and one of the pioneers of the world wide web, once declared: "The spread of computers and the internet will put jobs in two categories. People who tell computers what to do, and people who are told by computers what to do."

Andreessen has since repudiated this declaration, and taken a more optimistic stance. But economists, a more pessimistic bunch, are taking the possibility of this sort of bifurcated future more seriously.

As machine-learning technology enjoys rapid progress, more top researchers are investigating the question of what work will look like in a world filled with computers that can replicate or surpass many of humanity’s own mental abilities.

This is different from the scenario where robots take people’s jobs outright and leave humanity obsolete. While some economists claim to find signs of automation-induced unemployment, the amount is still very small, if it even exists at all. With the labor market having reached pre-recession levels, worries that jobs will become permanently scarce have quieted.

But that doesn’t mean the jobs people have in the future will be good ones. For decades, some economists have fretted about what they call skill-biased technological change, or the possibility that new technologies will reward those smart or mentally flexible enough to master them, while devaluing the skills of everyone else.

As computerisation proceeded in the 1980s, and as inequality rose, some economists worried that skill-biased technological change might already be having a big effect. But they probably jumped the gun.

A 2002 paper by labor economists David Card and John DiNardo observed that wage inequality stopped rising in the 1990s, even as computerisation accelerated. The authors also noted that the 1980s saw a diminution of the gender wage gap, despite the fact that women were less likely to have computer-intensive jobs.

But just because skill-biased technological change doesn’t explain the 1980s doesn’t mean it will never happen. In 2010, labor economist David Autor warned that routine tasks, jobs like assembly-line manufacturing or traditional office work, were being automated. These jobs use a lot of brain power, but in a predictable, repetitive way, exactly the kind of thing that computers can do better than humans. Autor found that his measures of routine task input were declining decade by decade:

It’s also possible that the “people who tell computers what to do,” and who therefore reap the benefits of the machine age, will not be workers, but business owners. Some economists believe that cheap technology is causing labor’s share of global income to decline.

A recent study by Autor and co-author Anna Salomons finds that since the 1970s, industries with faster productivity growth, international patenting and robot adoption have all seen labor lose out to capital.

That’s not a slam-dunk case, there are other reasons these factors could be hurting workers, and the rise of capital income could be mostly due to other forces. But this research raises the disturbing possibility that automation will lead to the final victory of capital over labor.

Now the worries about automation-induced inequality have increased, thanks to the stunning rise of machine learning. Since 2013, there has been a surge of interest in this new technology, which allows computers to do tasks like image and speech recognition that were previously the sole province of human brains.

Meanwhile, entrepreneurs and big businesses alike are dreaming of ways to use machine learning to replace a vast array of human tasks, from driving trucks to preparing food. Venture capitalists are pouring money into machine learning startups, often known by the trendy if inaccurate buzzword of “artificial intelligence”:

Economists, true to form as the dismal scientists, are concerned. If machine learning automates away low-skilled tasks, as some predict, it might not make working-class people obsolete, but it could make their existence miserable nonetheless.

It’s possible to imagine a future where lower-skilled people are constantly seeing their jobs get gobbled up by machines, forcing them to always be transitioning to new tasks, perpetually seeking a niche that hasn’t yet been devoured by ingenious entrepreneurs and their subservient robots, even as wages diminish. That scenario doesn’t necessarily involve high unemployment, but it’s hellish enough that it should worry people.

So what can be done to avert this future? The popular ideas include universal basic income, a federal job guarantee and subsidies for the employment of human workers. These are all ideas worth trying out on a modest scale, to see if they work; even if machine learning isn’t the threat some fear, they could be very helpful in reducing inequality.

Another idea is a social wealth fund, a government-managed fund or collection of funds that would use tax revenue to purchase shares in companies and distribute the dividends to citizens.

A social wealth fund would create a true ownership society, insuring the working populace against the rise of the robots by allowing each person to own a piece of those robots’ output. Ultimately, this seems like the simplest and most elegant solution.

Information Management:    Image: Nick Youngson

You Might Also Read: 

The Impact Of AI On Employment Demands New Thinking:

 

« UK Business Is Overconfident About Cybersecurity
Israel Wants Collaborators For Defence »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

CYRIN

CYRIN

CYRIN® Cyber Range. Real Tools, Real Attacks, Real Scenarios. See why leading educational institutions and companies in the U.S. have begun to adopt the CYRIN® system.

Perimeter 81 / How to Select the Right ZTNA Solution

Perimeter 81 / How to Select the Right ZTNA Solution

Gartner insights into How to Select the Right ZTNA offering. Download this FREE report for a limited time only.

Resecurity, Inc.

Resecurity, Inc.

Resecurity is a cybersecurity company that delivers a unified platform for endpoint protection, risk management, and cyber threat intelligence.

Practice Labs

Practice Labs

Practice Labs is an IT competency hub, where live-lab environments give access to real equipment for hands-on practice of essential cybersecurity skills.

Syxsense

Syxsense

Syxsense brings together endpoint management and security for greater efficiency and collaboration between IT management and security teams.

Radisys

Radisys

Radisys offers software, products, integrated systems, and professional services for communication service providers and telecom solution vendors.

CertiKit

CertiKit

CertiKit produce toolkit products that accelerate the adoption of ISO/IEC standards, including ISO 27001, helping organizations all over the world to realize the benefits as soon as possible.

InfoWatch

InfoWatch

InfoWatch solutions allow you to protect data and information assets that are critically important to your business.

Delta Risk

Delta Risk

Delta Risk is a global provider of managed security services and cyber security risk management solutions to government and private sector clients.

i-Sprint Innovations

i-Sprint Innovations

i-Sprint is a leader in Securing Identity and Transactions in the Cyber World for industries that are security sensitive.

Council for Information & Communication Technologies (CTIC)

Council for Information & Communication Technologies (CTIC)

CTIC was set up to address specific issues in the field of ICT relevant to the implementation of electronic government.

GuardianKey

GuardianKey

GuardianKey is a solution to protect systems against authentication attacks.

ZeroNorth

ZeroNorth

ZeroNorth provides a new approach to improve software and infrastructure security, simplify continuous compliance reporting and to create more cost-effective risk management programs.

Root9B (R9B)

Root9B (R9B)

R9B offers advanced cybersecurity products, services, and training to enhance the way organizations protect their networks.

Cyemptive Technologies

Cyemptive Technologies

Cyemptive's CyberSlice technology preempts and remove threats before they take hold, in seconds, compared to other’s hours, days, weeks and even months.

SyncDog

SyncDog

SyncDog is a leader in enterprise security and the preeminent vendor for containerized mobile application security across cloud & on-premise computing environments.

Digital Beachhead

Digital Beachhead

Digital Beachhead has the expertise to provide a range of Cyber Risk Management and other Professional Services with specifically tailored solutions at competitive prices.

CICRA Consultancies

CICRA Consultancies

Cicra Consultancies is a company that specializes in cyber security. Our major activities are guided by three main principles: Prevent, Investigate, Prosecute.

IN4 Group

IN4 Group

IN4 Group is a skills, innovation and start-up services provider that specialises in supporting businesses with the training, communities, networks and advice they need to scale.

Sekoia.io

Sekoia.io

Sekoia.io is a European cybersecurity company whose mission is to develop the best protection capabilities against cyber-attacks.

HP Wolf Security

HP Wolf Security

HP Wolf Security protects your organization and devices from cyberattacks no matter where, when or how you work.