State Sponsored Hackers: Finding The Country Behind The Attack

Security experts don't just want to know how a cyberattack happens, but what country the attack is coming from.

Headlines about hacking incidents have become commonplace, particularly in the recent months leading up to the US Presidential election. Whether it's breaches of voter registration systems, the US Democratic National Committee, or the World Anti-Doping Agency, experts are feverishly trying to figure out who is behind the crimes.

More specifically, they want to know whether a sovereign state could be supporting those attacks. Lately, they especially want to know if it's Russia.

Experts say the WADA perpetrators were Russian hackers operating under the banner "Fancy Bear," with several US officials pointing fingers at the Russian government specifically.

Moscow has repeatedly denied involvement with that group and other international cyberattacks.

So how do experts assess whether a country could be behind a hacking operation? It's often simple economics. "I think that you can certainly make the argument that this group of repeat offenders, known as Tsar Team (Fancy Bear), is backed up by a government (allegedly Russian intelligence agencies), not only because of the substantial amount of money needed ... but also because of its level of coordination and sophistication," said Francesca Spidalieri, senior fellow for cyber leadership at the Pell Center for International Relations and Public Policy.

Other experts emphasize technological factors. Steve Grobman, CTO at Intel Security, told CNBC that a lot of the technology needed to execute an attack are available on the black market, for example, and are not necessarily all that expensive. "A better indication of who an attack can be attributed to," he said, "comes when you actually get to take a look at things like the source code and can understand the level of sophistication something was built with."

Grobman's team analyzed a portion of the technical forensics associated with the World Anti-Doping Agency attack and concluded that there was insufficient evidence to definitively point the finger at the Russian government.

"We investigated the technical details that were publicly available around the WADA hacking case and compared them against other technical indicators and TTPs [tactics, techniques and procedures] we have gathered over the years," he said. "The amount of available technical details combined with some similar TTPs are not enough evidence in our opinion to attribute this campaign to a certain group or state-sponsored operation."

Scott Borg, director and chief economist at US Cyber Consequences Unit, an independent, non-profit research institute, told CNBC that he's confident the attack was carried out by Russian groups tasked with spreading Russian President Vladimir Putin's political and military agenda.  "This is as certain as anything can ever be in the cyber realm," he said. 

Borg said the Russian government maintains close relationships with many hacker groups, and said it has a history of other cyber-attack campaigns designed to influence political outcomes, particularly in Eastern European countries.

Russia is widely blamed for a broad campaign of cyberattacks against Estonia in 2007, though some experts still question whether there's enough evidence to connect the Kremlin to that attack.

"The hacker groups that the Russian government employs to do its bidding range from consulting groups regularly hired by the Russian government to criminal enterprises with which the Russian government only has slight, arms-length contact," Borg said.

Borg cautioned, though, that just because he believes a nation state was responsible for these attacks does not mean infiltrating the systems themselves required the resources of a country's government.

Matthew Prince, CEO of internet security firm CloudFlare, told CNBC he is skeptical about claims that the Russian government is funding the latest spate of hacks. "The power of computers and of a single determined individual to be able to cause great harm, even if they are not well-financed, is pretty astonishing," he said.

The bottom line, said Bruce Schneier, security expert and CTO at Resilient, an IBM company, is that in terms of figuring out who's really behind a hack, "it's incredibly complicated."

"We do the best we can, but it's not great," Schneier said. "Attribution is just hard in cyber space."

CNBC:

 

« Drone-Visuality: The Psychology Of Killing
Difficult: Attracting Women To Cybersecurity »

ManageEngine
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Check Point

Directory of Suppliers

ZenGRC

ZenGRC

ZenGRC (formerly Reciprocity) is a leader in the GRC SaaS landscape, offering robust and intuitive products designed to make compliance straightforward and efficient.

Jooble

Jooble

Jooble is a job search aggregator operating in 71 countries worldwide. We simplify the job search process by displaying active job ads from major job boards and career sites across the internet.

ManageEngine

ManageEngine

As the IT management division of Zoho Corporation, ManageEngine prioritizes flexible solutions that work for all businesses, regardless of size or budget.

IT Governance

IT Governance

IT Governance is a leading global provider of information security solutions. Download our free guide and find out how ISO 27001 can help protect your organisation's information.

Lunar

Lunar

Lunar is a free, enterprise-grade, compromised-credentials monitoring platform, available to every company, everywhere.

Lacuna Talent

Lacuna Talent

Lacuna Talent delivers the combined power of Via Resource, the international Cyber Security recruiter, and Lacuna Talent, the Specialist AI/Data recruiter.

2|SEC Consulting (2-SEC)

2|SEC Consulting (2-SEC)

At 2|SEC Consulting, we deliver an end-to-end service of cyber and information security solutions which are tailored to each client’s exact security needs.

Digittrade

Digittrade

Digittrade develop and produce external encrypted hard disks and secure communications apps.

H-11 Digital Forensics

H-11 Digital Forensics

H-11 Digital Forensics is a global leader of digital forensic technology.

Hysolate

Hysolate

Hysolate has transformed the endpoint, making it the secure and productive environment it was meant to be.

Trinity Cyber

Trinity Cyber

Trinity Cyber’s patent-pending technology stops attacks before they reach internal networks,reducing risk and increasing cost to adversaries.

Cyber Tec Security

Cyber Tec Security

Cyber Tec Security is an IASME Certification Body for Cyber Essentials basic/Plus. We also provide ongoing Managed Security Services.

2Keys

2Keys

2Keys designs, deploys and operates Digital Identity Platforms and Cyber Security Platforms through Managed Service and Professional Service engagements.

South West Cyber Resilience Centre (SWCRC)

South West Cyber Resilience Centre (SWCRC)

The South West Cyber Resilience Centre (SWCRC) is led by serving police officers, as part of a not-for-profit partnership with business and academia.

Material Security

Material Security

Material is solving one of the most fundamental problems in security: protecting the data sitting in mailboxes.

Aceiss

Aceiss

Aceiss empowers access security, providing unprecedented visibility and insights into user access.

HTL Support

HTL Support

HTL Support, your trusted partner for comprehensive IT support in London. We specialize in delivering top-tier IT solutions tailored to both large enterprises and small businesses.

LockMagic

LockMagic

Lockmagic is an information asset management solution to protect, track, audit and control accesses to sensitive information inside and outside your organization.

Alpha Echo

Alpha Echo

Specialising in security advice and enterprise-wide Cyberworthiness, Alpha Echo helps Australia deliver on cyber outcomes at a military grade level.

Skylark

Skylark

Skylark is a leading global IT services provider, transforming client’s businesses through innovative and advanced technology solutions.

Modat

Modat

Modat is an AI-powered, research-driven company focused on developing products and services that enable cybersecurity professionals to outpace adversaries.