Stolen Health Records Flooding Dark Web Markets

According to new research provided to CyberScoop and conducted by the Institute for Critical Infrastructure Technology and cybersecurity firms Flashpoint and Intel Security, the large amount of leaked patient records stolen and posted for sale to the dark web in recent months has caused prices for most of those records to drop.

In the face of exceeding supply, stagnant demand and increased law enforcement attention, it’s becoming increasingly difficult for criminals to make a living selling partial healthcare records, according to James Scott, a senior fellow at ICIT.

While the quality, quantity and sometimes origin of such electronic records will help dictate the price of any specific package for sale, average prices are largely trending downwards for individual, non-financial files, new research shows.

The value of similar healthcare records that sold last year for roughly $75 to $100 dollars can now be found for around $20 to $50 dollars.

“The volume of medical data for sale in the criminal underground is increasing, leading to very low prices for individual records,” Vitali Kremez, a senior analyst focused on cyber intelligence at Flashpoint, told CyberScoop.

A majority of stolen healthcare patient records sold on the dark web come from US-based institutions that have been breached, according to Intel Security.

The average price for a single complete electronic health record, described as a “fullz” in underground markets, typically tagged with financial information and supporting documents like utility bills or insurance receipts, currently hovers around $50, World Privacy Forum founder Pam Dixon recently estimated.

In broad strokes, an electronic healthcare record is rarely worth very much unless it is converted into a “complete ID kit,” which combines long form healthcare records, additional documents and are authorised via a breached government registration database, explained Scott.

Even so, because healthcare records contain vast personal information, these document offer scammers a stepping stone to more comprehensive fraud schemes.

Dixon told Healthcare IT News that decreasing prices are a general conclusion of easier access to sensitive personal records. One component of this eased access, based upon data gathered by ICIT and Intel Security, is the growing sale of hacking-as-a-service on the dark web, which enables those without technical backgrounds to hack into systems by relying on paid mercenaries.

Laying the groundwork for a further discordant dark web economy in some part, according to Kremez and Intel Security vice president Raj Samani, is also the ambiguous rise of prominent, dedicated healthcare hackers. Two of these mysterious actors, known simply by their vendor usernames “earthbound11” and “the dark-overlord,” have been flooding the market with medical fullz in recent months, thereby dictating the price for other smaller resellers.

A hacker’s underground reputation is typically one of the leading factors leading to the valuation and eventual sale of any records package they post, research shows.

“The larger trend in the trade of compromised personal healthcare information is toward larger breaches affecting more data,” said Kremez, “cyber-criminals themselves have realised that the value of their stolen medical data is much lower than once expected.”

Though it remains unclear how a recent fall in Dark Web prices have and now continue to influence hackers’ attack behavior towards the healthcare industry, several experts who spoke with CyberScoop believe it will ultimately lead to a spike in overall network intrusions at hospitals, the counter-intuitive thinking here being that larger data dumps will help dark web vendors recoup recent profit losses.

“After the 2015 breach of 100 million medical records from Anthem, Premera Blue Cross, and Excellus Health Plan, let alone the numerous smaller networks compromised in 2015 and 2016, the annual rate of medical identity theft could easily increase to be ten or twenty times greater than the 2014 rate,” an extensive, recent Dark Web report from ICIT reads.

Unlike stolen credit card details and other payment information sold online, however, a cloud of uncertainty looms over leaked healthcare records because cause and effect is difficult to decipher, said Samani. According to an April 2014 FBI bulletin, electronic healthcare record theft is also more difficult to detect, taking almost twice as long to spot as normal identity theft.

In most cases, the data necessary to draw a conclusive connection between a leaked patient record and relevant case of identity fraud, for example, is neither readily available nor visible The result is an environment where targeted data breaches occur but security researchers cannot definitely say how some, if not most, of the leaked information is being used, explained Samani.

“The impact of stolen payment cards is felt almost immediately whereas other forms of data the impact could be longer term,” said Samani, “indeed we can determine a direct correlation between a breach, and the pain felt when cards are declined. But it is not so easy to determine the origin of fraud with other forms of data.”

AIRS:     Why Are Hackers After Healthcare Records?:      Healthcare Data Breaches In 2017 Will Get Worse:

You Might Also Read:

Google Challenged For Collecting American Health Data:

 

« Give Children More Control Of Data Privacy
Non-Secure IoT Devices Are Powerful Weapons »

ManageEngine
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Check Point

Directory of Suppliers

IT Governance

IT Governance

IT Governance is a leading global provider of information security solutions. Download our free guide and find out how ISO 27001 can help protect your organisation's information.

LockLizard

LockLizard

Locklizard provides PDF DRM software that protects PDF documents from unauthorized access and misuse. Share and sell documents securely - prevent document leakage, sharing and piracy.

Resecurity

Resecurity

Resecurity is a cybersecurity company that delivers a unified platform for endpoint protection, risk management, and cyber threat intelligence.

Syxsense

Syxsense

Syxsense brings together endpoint management and security for greater efficiency and collaboration between IT management and security teams.

Tines

Tines

The Tines security automation platform helps security teams automate manual tasks, making them more effective and efficient.

QMS International

QMS International

QMS is one of the leading ISO certification bodies in the UK and serves clients worldwide.

SI-CERT

SI-CERT

SI-CERT (Slovenian Computer Emergency Response Team) is the national cyber scurity incident response center for Slovenia.

Siepel

Siepel

Siepel manufactures high quality shielded rooms and anechoic chambers dedicated to TEMPEST, NEMP & HIRF.

ClearDATA

ClearDATA

The ClearDATA Managed Cloud protects sensitive healthcare data using purpose-built DevOps automation, compliance and security safeguards, and healthcare expertise.

LIFARS

LIFARS

LIFARS is a global leader in Digital Forensics and Cyber Resiliency Services.

Unitrends

Unitrends

Unitrends helps IT pros do more with less by providing an all-in-one enterprise backup and continuity solution.

Charities Security Forum (CSF)

Charities Security Forum (CSF)

The Charities Security Forum is the premier membership group for information security people working for charities and not-for-profits in the UK.

OmniCyber Security

OmniCyber Security

Omni is a cyber security firm specialising in Penetration Testing, Managed Security and Compliance.

LiveAction

LiveAction

LiveAction provides end-to-end visibility of network and application performance from a single pane of glass.

Flat6Labs

Flat6Labs

Flat6Labs is the MENA region’s leading seed and early stage venture capital firm, currently running the most renowned startup programs in the region.

Primary Guard

Primary Guard

Primary Guard provides IT solutions and computing technologies that help minimize impact from cyber threats, improve business efficiency and maintain essential functions during or after a disaster.

Memcyco

Memcyco

Memcyco is a provider of cutting-edge digital trust technologies to empower brands in combating online brand impersonation fraud, and preventing fraud damages to businesses and their clients.

Washington Technology Solutions (WaTech)

Washington Technology Solutions (WaTech)

WaTech operates the state’s core technology infrastructure – the central network and data center, provides strategic direction for cybersecurity and protects state networks from growing cyber threats.

Inveo Group

Inveo Group

Inveo group is the Italian leader for the management of privacy and data protection issues.

GrayHats

GrayHats

GrayHats is a platform-based cybersecurity company devoted to delivering comprehensive, scalable, and proactive protection for businesses in an ever-evolving threat landscape.

Auraya

Auraya

Auraya develops its next generation voice biometric AI to deliver easy-to-use and highly secure speaker recognition and fraud detection capabilities.