The Apps That Map Violence

Rejecting official information channels, Rio’s citizens are navigating their city using crowdsourced data on shootings and robberies as they happen

A red spot on the map means gunfire, so I avoid going there,” says Leonardo Duarte, who works on the streets for a rehabilitation clinic in Rio de Janeiro. Shootings and violence are routine in his neighbourhood of Vigário Geral, a slum in the grip of conflict between rival drug-trafficking gangs.

To stay out of danger when navigating the City he has a strategy: never go anywhere without checking his phone for live crime data.

An increasing number of Rio residents are subscribing to crowdsourcing apps and following the social network pages of crime-watch groups such as Basta de Violência (No More Violence) and Realidade do Rio de Janeiro (Reality of Rio de Janeiro).

These new sources of real-time information are shaping how many residents navigate the rising day-to-day violence in the city – which is currently the subject of a controversial military security intervention. Duarte updates the groups if he comes across a violent episode. “I send out information when I see or hear something,” he says.

Duarte’s daily decisions are based mainly on the mobile app Onde Tem Tiroteio (OTT, or Where the Shootouts Are), which sends out alerts for incidents across Rio de Janeiro state. Set up in 2016 by four friends, OTT tracks gun and gang violence based on residents’ reports. It has grown fast.

Co-founder Dennis Coli explains that he and his friends take turns managing the operation, which receives 80 to 100 alerts every day from a network of 1 million people. They include subscribers to the app and followers on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, WhatsApp and Telegram.

OTT eschews official statistics. Instead, it crowdsources data on shootings and arrastões (organised gang looting) and checks these anonymous reports with a core WhatsApp network of 2,000 people who OTT considers reliable. Only 10% of the original crowdsourced reports reach the public. “We don’t want to spawn unnecessary chaos,” says Coli.

The four founders had all experienced violence before starting the self-financed voluntary project. In 2015, Coli had a gun pointed at him when he unwittingly stopped his car in a spot used by drug dealers.

Two years after releasing the app, he admits feeling even more frightened, but says the app’s database means he can avoid problem areas. “I anticipate,” he says. “For example, I never drive on highways such as Linha Vermelha, Dutra and Brasil on Sunday afternoons. There is always an incident.”

The Fogo Cruzado (Crossfire) app, set up by Amnesty International and now managed by the Update Institute, is similar. It cross-checks reports from a range of sources, including journalists, police officers and residents, across Greater Rio de Janeiro. It also trawls official police and press data. It reports an average of 16 shootouts a day across Greater Rio, compared with OTT’s 14 across Rio state.

“These incidents were happening already,” says Crossfire co-founder and journalist Cecília Olliveira, who designed the app after failing to find statistics on stray bullets for a story. “The difference is that we count them now. I’m quite sure they are still underreported.”

Last month Olliveira posted on Fogo Cruzado about gunshots close by Praça da Bandeira. Later she realised they were the shots that killed the Rio city councillor Marielle Franco, whose murder led thousands of outraged Brazilians to protest on the streets. Olliveira knew her personally. “This is the third time a gunshot I posted about hit someone I know,” she says. “Two of them have died.”

Robert Muggah, research director of the Igarapé Institute think-tank, says Fogo Cruzado and OTT fill knowledge gaps and redirect the discussion of crime away from distant trends and toward its immediate impacts. Igarapé’s own app, CrimeRadar, uses artificial intelligence to analyse 14m official crime reports from the past five years and predict crime patterns across the city.

But Muggah cautions that Facebook crime-watch groups can be “exceedingly conservative”, often calling for severe sentencing legislation and featuring “racist and pejorative” headlines and text. “They have certainly expanded the spread of fake news,” he adds.

Rio’s military police would rather residents consulted their official Twitter, Instagram, Facebook and YouTube accounts. “There is a lot of misinformation circulating on the internet,” says its press office.

But for many, the immediacy of the apps wins out. As Jaciara da Conceição looks at her smartphone, audio alerts and images from WhatsApp pop up on her screen. She hates seeing the graphic photographs of young men’s mutilated bodies, “but it is difficult to avoid getting them”, she says.

When a drug-related conflict broke out in her Greater Rio neighbourhood of Parque Paulista a few months ago, four public buses were set on fire. She saw the flames of one from her window, and heard about the others on a Facebook page.

Conceição says she was sceptical when she heard that a drug dealer was advising people to avoid the streets, but the following day the shootings restarted: “So it was true.”

Guardian:

You Might Also Read: 

Smartphone Apps Covertly Report Your Location Data:

True Cost of Cybercrime in Brazil:

 

« A New Distributed Database Adds GDPR Controls
How AI & Machine Learning Can Revolutionise eCommerce »

ManageEngine
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Check Point

Directory of Suppliers

Keygraph

Keygraph

Keygraph builds AI penetration testing for application security teams. Keygraph also builds Shannon, a leading open-source AI pentester

CSI Consulting Services

CSI Consulting Services

Get Advice From The Experts: * Training * Penetration Testing * Data Governance * GDPR Compliance. Connecting you to the best in the business.

Clayden Law

Clayden Law

Clayden Law advise global businesses that buy and sell technology products and services. We are experts in information technology, data privacy and cybersecurity law.

ManageEngine

ManageEngine

As the IT management division of Zoho Corporation, ManageEngine prioritizes flexible solutions that work for all businesses, regardless of size or budget.

NordLayer

NordLayer

NordLayer is an adaptive network access security solution for modern businesses — from the world’s most trusted cybersecurity brand, Nord Security. 

Apricorn

Apricorn

Apricorn provides hardware-based 256-bit encrypted external storage products to companies and organizations that require high-level protection for their data at rest.

authUSB

authUSB

authUSB Safe Door is a tool that provides secure access to the content of USB devices that circulate in organizations.

Eperi

Eperi

Eperi is a leading provider of Cloud Data Protection (CDP) solutions with 15 years of experience in data encryption for databases, (SaaS) applications and files.

Alias Robotics

Alias Robotics

Alias Robotics is a robot cyber security company. We deliver cyber security solutions for robots and robot components.

AgileBlue (Agile1)

AgileBlue (Agile1)

AgileBlue (formerly Agile1) is a managed breach detection company with an Autonomous SOC-as-a-Service for 24×7 monitoring, detection and guided response.

Capgemini

Capgemini

Capgemini is one of the world's foremost providers of consulting, technology and outsourcing services. Areas of expertise include Cybersecurity.

GoodAccess

GoodAccess

GoodAccess is the cybersecurity platform that gives your business the security benefits of zero trust without the complexities so your users can securely access digital resources anytime, anywhere.

PROVINTELL Cyber Security

PROVINTELL Cyber Security

PROVINTELL is a Managed Security Service Provider (MSSP) specialising in Next-Gen Cyber Defense and Response to detect and respond to threats.

Panoptic Cyber

Panoptic Cyber

Panoptic Cyber are a team of elite Armed Forces Veterans who hold a wealth of experience in Information Security, Cyber Security, Data Protection and Risk Management.

OmniIndex

OmniIndex

OmniIndex PostgresBC is the only commercial solution allowing you to keep your most sensitive and critical data encrypted while analyzing it. Structured and unstructured.

TisOva

TisOva

TisOva is an innovative cybersecurity startup dedicated to addressing the growing issue of online scams targeting students.

Gcore

Gcore

Gcore is an international leader in public cloud and edge computing, content delivery, hosting, and security solutions.

Qodea

Qodea

Qodea (formerly Appsbroker CTS) is Europe's largest Google Premier only transformation partner.

CodeSecure

CodeSecure

CodeSecure provides industry-leading static application security testing (SAST) tools that help organizations identify and remediate vulnerabilities early in the development lifecycle.

BTMS

BTMS

BTMS advances national security by providing secure, scalable solutions for defense and intelligence.

Security Architect

Security Architect

Security Architect is a leading provider of IT and cybersecurity solutions, at the forefront of technological protection and innovation for enterprise companies.