The Internet Is No Place For Elections

Despite what election officials may tell you, you can’t trust the Internet with your vote.

This US election year foreign hackers infiltrated the Democratic National Committee’s e-mail system as well as voter databases in Arizona and Illinois. These attacks have reinforced what political scientists and technical experts alike have been saying for more than a decade: public elections should stay offline. It’s not yet feasible to build a secure and truly democratic Internet-connected voting system.

Researchers from government agencies and leading academic institutions studied the issue extensively following the debacle of the 2000 presidential race, and the consensus emerged that it should not occur. That’s still the case, and today’s rampant cybercrime should be reason enough to keep voting systems disconnected. We have no good defense against malware on voters’ computers or denial of service attacks, and sophisticated adversaries like those behind the attacks on big corporations we’ve seen in recent years will find ways to get into connected voting systems, says Ron Rivest, a leading cryptographer and MIT professor. “It’s a war zone out there,” he says.

Nevertheless, 32 states and the District of Columbia allow at least some absentee voters (in most cases just voters who live overseas or serve in the military) to return their completed ballots using poorly secured e-mail, Internet-connected fax machines, or websites. In the most extreme example, all voters in Alaska are allowed to return their completed ballots over a supposedly secure website. 

And there is a danger that Internet voting could expand. Vendors like the Spanish company Scytl, which supplied Alaska’s system, and Southern California-based Everyone Counts keep marketing these systems to election boards against the advice of security experts. And they haven’t opened their systems to public security testing.

In some cases, election officials don’t have enough technical background to distrust claims from vendors, says Pamela Smith, president of Verified Voting, a non-profit group that advocates for greater integrity and verifiability in elections. Terms like “military-grade encryption” or “unhackable” should be red flags, she says.

Even if the risk of cybercrime could be mitigated, building an online voting system that preserves the core components we expect from democratic elections would be technically complex. Today’s commercial systems do not achieve this; most of the states that offer ballot return via the Internet ask that voters first waive their right to a secret ballot. The key challenge is building an online system that generates some sort of credible evidence that proves the outcome “is what you say it is” during an audit, while maintaining voter privacy and the secret ballot, says Rivest.

In principle, this can be done using cryptography. But while there are cryptographic protocols that can help solve the “integrity and privacy facets” of Internet voting, the technology would be difficult for many people to use, says Joseph Kiniry, a voting technology expert and the CEO and chief scientist for Free & Fair, a startup that develops open-source, verifiable election technologies and services. That’s a disqualifier for use in democratic elections.

Kiniry, who also advises the US government on election technology via public working groups, was the technical lead on a recent project to examine the feasibility of “end-to-end verifiable Internet voting.” Such a system would rely on encryption to secure votes, keep them private, and make them verifiable after they are cast. The team of cryptographers (including Rivest), computer scientists, and other election experts, in collaboration with the US Vote Foundation, published a comprehensive report last year, concluding that many challenges remain in creating an Internet voting system.

Compared with a traditional, supervised voting system in a polling station, an Internet voting system requires “several hundred” additional technical properties for it to be suitable for elections, says Kiniry. “If someone builds a system that fulfills those properties and can prove it, great, then let’s use it,” he says. “But until we can do that, we just don’t have democratic voting infrastructure when it comes to Internet voting.”

Technology Review

 

 

« IBM’s Real -Time Cloud Platform For Financial Services
Otto: Uber Acquires Self-Driving Lorry Startup »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

ManageEngine

ManageEngine

As the IT management division of Zoho Corporation, ManageEngine prioritizes flexible solutions that work for all businesses, regardless of size or budget.

Jooble

Jooble

Jooble is a job search aggregator operating in 71 countries worldwide. We simplify the job search process by displaying active job ads from major job boards and career sites across the internet.

LockLizard

LockLizard

Locklizard provides PDF DRM software that protects PDF documents from unauthorized access and misuse. Share and sell documents securely - prevent document leakage, sharing and piracy.

Cyber Security Supplier Directory

Cyber Security Supplier Directory

Our Supplier Directory lists 6,000+ specialist cyber security service providers in 128 countries worldwide. IS YOUR ORGANISATION LISTED?

NordLayer

NordLayer

NordLayer is an adaptive network access security solution for modern businesses — from the world’s most trusted cybersecurity brand, Nord Security. 

European Digital Media Association (EDiMA)

European Digital Media Association (EDiMA)

EDiMA, is the European trade association representing online platforms. It is an alliance of new media and Internet companies.

Latham & Watkins LLP

Latham & Watkins LLP

Latham & Watkins is an international law firm. Practice areas include Data Privacy, Security and Cybercrime.

National Cyber Security Centre Portugal (CNCS)

National Cyber Security Centre Portugal (CNCS)

CNCS is the operational coordinator and Portuguese national authority in cybersecurity working with State entities, and digital service providers

MerlinCryption

MerlinCryption

MerlinCryption develops infrastructure security software, delivering advanced encryption, authentication, and random data generators, for Cloud, VoIP, eCommerce, M2M, and USB hardware.

Post-Quantum

Post-Quantum

Post-Quantum offer a unique, patented quantum-resistant encryption algorithm that can be applied to existing products and networks.

SCADAfence

SCADAfence

SCADAfence offers cutting edge cybersecurity solutions designed to ensure the operational continuity of industrial (ICS/SCADA) networks.

La Fosse Associates

La Fosse Associates

The InfoSec Recruitment team at La Fosse Associates specialises in placing Information Security & Risk professionals on a permanent and contract basis.

GV

GV

GV provides venture capital funding to bold new companies in the fields of life science, healthcare, artificial intelligence, robotics, transportation, cyber security and agriculture.

SearchInform

SearchInform

SearchInform is a leading risk management product developer, protecting business and government institutions against data theft, harmful human behavior, compliance breaches and incomplete audit.

SecureLayer7

SecureLayer7

SecureLayer7 is an international provider of integrated business information security solutions with an innovative approach to IT security.

National Academy of Cyber Security (NACS)

National Academy of Cyber Security (NACS)

National Academy of Cyber Security provides Professional Training Courses and Programmes in Cyber Security.

Redpoint Security

Redpoint Security

Redpoint Security is an application security consulting firm that is focused on all aspects of code security.

Wazuh

Wazuh

Wazuh is a free, open source and enterprise-ready security monitoring solution for threat detection, integrity monitoring, incident response and compliance.

Valtix

Valtix

Valtix is the first and only multi-cloud network security platform delivered as a service that enables cloud teams to meet the most stringent security requirements in a cloud-first & simple way.

Training.com.au

Training.com.au

Training.com.au is a comparison website through which those looking to learn about different aspects of cyber security can compare learning courses from training providers from across Australia.

Trustaira

Trustaira

Trustaira is the first deep tech solution and service company in Bangladesh.