The Shadow IT Problem No One Talks About

Everyone worries about shadow IT-employees downloading apps you don’t know about, using their personal devices for work, and sending business-critical information over WhatsApp. These seemingly unimportant services are out of sight, but that doesn’t mean they’re out of mind.  

But while you may have already considered - and planned for - the security headaches arising from those scenarios, there’s another, harder-to-spot danger lurking in the shadows. 

This hidden hazard? Network complexity. When networks become tangled, knotty new shadow IT problems can become tied up with them – things like unseen vulnerabilities, misconfigured tools, and security gaps no one is monitoring.

When IT teams lack full visibility and control over their network infrastructure, it’s only a matter of time before an attacker slips through the cracks. Just as an unauthorised app can compromise an employee’s phone, a tangled, multilayered network leaves gaps wide open for a bad actor to exploit.

Shadow IT vs. Shadow Complexity

So, we know that shadow IT refers to unapproved apps and services operating outside official oversight. Shadow complexity, therefore, can be thought of as the challenge that arises from the accumulation of layer upon layer of infrastructure, misconfigured security tools, redundant policies, and compliance gaps that exist beyond clear visibility.

As security stacks grow, they become harder to manage. This is where the problem compounds: IT and security teams may believe they have full control, but they can’t see the blind spots that have developed along the way. In other words, they no longer know what they don’t know. 

With so many different policies, tools, and configurations at play, vulnerabilities remain hidden. These gaps can persist for months - or even years - before being detected, leaving the door open for breaches.

Redundant & Conflicting Security Policies

Many large organisations rely on multiple security and monitoring tools, whether that’s firewalls, endpoint security, SIEM, RMM tools, and much more. This isn’t an issue in and of itself, of course. But issues do arrive when overlapping rules across different platforms create inconsistencies. Some areas may be overly strict, while others are left exposed. Who has visibility over all of these rules? 

Take the example of the legacy system that should have been decommissioned but remains connected due to dependency fears. IT teams worry that removing old servers or applications could disrupt business functions, so they remain operational, often without proper security updates. The thinking goes something like: there’s no danger here, it’s an old system, a back-up. But this lack of oversight can quickly morph into a significant security risk.

In March 2020, data from UK train commuters using free Wi-Fi at Network Rail-managed stations was exposed due to a misconfiguration in AWS cloud storage. The database was found online, without a password. The Wi-Fi provider assumed the storage was restricted to internal access only, not realising that this personal information was accessible to all. They later claimed the database was simply a backup. This case illustrates both how simple misconfigurations can lead to major security lapses, and also the importance of securing all files, data, and devices–whether they’re currently in use or not.

Compliance Gaps From Poor Visibility

Many businesses operate under multiple compliance frameworks, like GDPR, ISO 27001, Cyber Essentials, NIS2, and more. And with every passing year, a new cybersecurity or data protection framework seems to be announced. Complexity in your systems makes it difficult to track what’s actually compliant.

Consider a company using multiple cloud environments, each with its own security controls and compliance standards. Without a unified approach, security teams may not realise they’re out of compliance until an audit flags critical issues. Worse still, these compliance gaps may leave the organisation exposed to regulatory fines or reputational damage.

Why Your Security Approach May Fail Against Shadow Complexity

Security tools don’t work well in silos. 

Layering multiple security tools and frameworks on top of each other may seem like a solid strategy, but without centralised, well-organised visibility that operates at speed and scale, complexity creates gaps.

Manual processes simply can’t keep up. IT teams are already overwhelmed by alerts, policies, and ever-changing attack vectors. Small misconfigurations go unnoticed, and cybercriminals actively look for these unmonitored systems and vulnerabilities.

Additionally, ransomware groups frequently move laterally through unpatched or poorly secured systems, leveraging these blind spots. The complexity of modern IT environments provides a perfect playground for these attacks, allowing cybercriminals to exploit security weaknesses before they are even discovered.

How to Bring Shadow Complexity Into The Light

Prioritise Visibility: If you can’t see your hybrid infrastructure, attack surfaces, compliance posture, or pending patches, how can you assess risk? Without a consolidated monitoring system, your security infrastructure might resemble a flatpack from the world’s most famous Nordic furniture store without instructions or the right fixings. You simply have no idea how it all fits together.

Implementing a single-pane-of-glass security platform that consolidates asset management, compliance tracking, and monitoring is crucial. 

Automate Where Possible: Once you have clear visibility (and have finally broken ground on assembling that flatpack bed), automation can help maintain security rule updates and ensure policies remain consistent across cloud and on-prem environments.

Automated patch management and compliance reporting can remove human error from security operations, ensuring that risks are identified and remediated before they escalate.

Simplify Your Security Stack: Identify and eliminate security tools that are no longer serving their purpose. An overcomplicated setup burdens teams, drains budgets, and increases security gaps. Reducing unnecessary moving parts means fewer vulnerabilities to track and verify.

And finally, conducting regular audits of security policies and tools ensures that your security stack remains effective, rather than becoming a tangled mess that creates more risks than it mitigates.

Complexity itself is a security threat and needs to be treated as one. Businesses are so quick to invest heavily in firewalls, threat intelligence, and compliance programs, yet often overlook the hidden risk created by their own infrastructure.

A tangled, overly complex security architecture does nothing but create vulnerabilities. Without a proactive approach to simplifying and securing networks, organisations leave themselves exposed to breaches, compliance failures, and operational inefficiencies.

Just as shadow IT needs to be managed, shadow complexity must be brought into the light. Because what you can’t see can still hurt you.

David Brown is SVP International Business, at FireMon

Image: SergeyNivens

You Might Also Read: 

The Power Of Unified Cloud Protection:


If you like this website and use the comprehensive 7,000-plus service supplier Directory, you can get unrestricted access, including the exclusive in-depth Directors Report series, by signing up for a Premium Subscription.

  • Individual £5 per month or £50 per year. Sign Up
  • Multi-User, Corporate & Library Accounts Available on Request

Cyber Security Intelligence: Captured Organised & Accessible


 

« Data Breaches Cause A Financial Burden
ZTNA - Back To Basics »

Infosecurity Europe
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

Resecurity

Resecurity

Resecurity is a cybersecurity company that delivers a unified platform for endpoint protection, risk management, and cyber threat intelligence.

Infosecurity Europe, 3-5 June 2025, ExCel London

Infosecurity Europe, 3-5 June 2025, ExCel London

This year, Infosecurity Europe marks 30 years of bringing the global cybersecurity community together to further our joint mission of Building a Safer Cyber World.

ZenGRC

ZenGRC

ZenGRC (formerly Reciprocity) is a leader in the GRC SaaS landscape, offering robust and intuitive products designed to make compliance straightforward and efficient.

Alvacomm

Alvacomm

Alvacomm offers holistic VIP cybersecurity services, providing comprehensive protection against cyber threats. Our solutions include risk assessment, threat detection, incident response.

TÜV SÜD Academy UK

TÜV SÜD Academy UK

TÜV SÜD offers expert-led cybersecurity training to help organisations safeguard their operations and data.

International Security Management Association (ISMA)

International Security Management Association (ISMA)

ISMA is an international security association of senior security executives from major business organizations located worldwide.

Nexus Group

Nexus Group

Nexus Group develops identity solutions for physical and digital access.

Qufaro

Qufaro

Qufaro is a new initiative designed to make it simpler for those with career ambitions in cyber security to access the UK’s cyber-specific education and innovation opportunities.

DAkkS

DAkkS

DAkkS is the national accreditation body for Germany. The directory of members provides details of organisations offering certification services for ISO 27001.

Inavate Consulting

Inavate Consulting

Inavate Consulting are experts in defining and implementing information assurance solutions and governance frameworks. Our ISO27001 consultants are the most experienced in the industry.

Texas A&M Cybersecurity Center

Texas A&M Cybersecurity Center

Texas A&M Cybersecurity Center is dedicated to combating adversaries who desire to harm our citizens, our government, and our industry through cyber-attacks.

DisruptOps

DisruptOps

Built for today’s cloud-scale enterprises, DisruptOps’ Cloud Detection and Response platform automates assessment and remediation procedures of critical cloud security issues.

Immuta

Immuta

Immuta empowers data engineering and operations teams to automate data governance, security, access control & privacy protection.

UncommonX

UncommonX

UncommonX offers enterprise-class cybersecurity protection for mid-size organizations by combining adaptive threat and intelligence software with 24/7 industry experts.

Shorebreak Security

Shorebreak Security

Shorebreak Securioty specialize in conducting highly accurate, safe, and reliable Information Security tests to determine the risks posed to your business.

N2K Networks

N2K Networks

N2K Networks is the world’s first “news to knowledge” network. The news to knowledge network is how you stay at the cutting edge in a rapidly changing world.

Novem CS

Novem CS

Novem CS are bespoke cyber security specialists providing a highly effective and specialised approach to solving your cyber security challenges.

Forward Networks

Forward Networks

Forward Networks - transforming networks to be more reliable, agile, and secure.

Scalarr

Scalarr

Scalarr is an innovative, next-generation cyber security firm focused on automation and AI to detect and prevent threats in mobile and Edge/IoT infrastructures.

IDCARE

IDCARE

IDCARE is Australia and New Zealand’s national identity & cyber support service. Our service is the only one of its type in the world.

Loccus AI

Loccus AI

Loccus are developers of AI solutions in the voice safety space. We build identity verification solutions, deepfake detection systems and fraud protection products for companies and end-users.