UK Health Service Should Have Prevented WannaCry Attack

NHS trusts were left vulnerable in a major ransomware attack in May because cyber-security recommendations were not followed, a government report has said.
 
More than a third of trusts in England were disrupted by the WannaCry ransomware, according to the UK National Audit Office (NAO).
 
At least 6,900 NHS appointments were cancelled as a result of the attack. NHS England said no patient data had been compromised or stolen and praised the staff response.The NAO chief said the Department of Health and the NHS must now "get their act together".
 
WannaCry, which spread to more than 150 countries in a worldwide ransomware outbreak beginning on 12 May, was the biggest cyber-attack to have hit the NHS to date. The malware encrypted data on infected computers and demanded a ransom roughly equivalent to £230 ($300). The NAO report said there was no evidence that any NHS organisation paid the ransom, but the financial cost of the incident remained unknown. An assessment of 88 out of 236 trusts by NHS Digital before the attack found that none passed the required cyber-security standards.
 
The report said NHS trusts had not acted on critical alerts from NHS Digital and a warning from the Department of Health and the Cabinet Office in 2014 to patch or migrate away from vulnerable older software. The Department of Health also lacked important information, the report said. "Before 12 May 2017, the department had no formal mechanism for assessing whether NHS organisations had complied with its advice and guidance."
 
Organisations could also have better managed their computers' firewalls - but in many cases they did not, it said.
NHS organisations have not reported any cases of harm to patients or of their data being stolen as a result of WannaCry.
NHS England has identified 6,912 appointments - including operations - that were cancelled as a direct result of the ransomware.
 
It estimated that about 19,000 appointments in total may have been affected. Cases included at least 139 people potentially with cancer, who had urgent referrals cancelled. It is not known: 
  • how many GP appointments were cancelled
  • how many ambulances and individuals were diverted from five accident and emergency departments unable to treat some patients
  • how many trusts or GPs experienced delays in information, such as test results
The NAO credits the widely reported work of cyber-security researcher Marcus Hutchins, who accidentally helped to stop the spread of WannaCry. His "kill switch" involved registering a domain name linked to the malware, which deactivated the program's ability to spread automatically.
 
Home Office Minister Ben Wallace was reported to say that the government was "as sure as possible" that North Korea was behind the attack."This attack, we believe quite strongly that it came from a foreign state," he said. "It is widely believed in the community and across a number of countries that North Korea [took on] this role". Former chairman of NHS Digital, Kingsley Manning, said that a failure to upgrade old computer systems at a local level within the NHS had contributed to the rapid spread of the malware. He said: "The problem with cyber security for the NHS is [that] it has a particular vulnerability... It's very interconnected so if you get an attack in one place it tends to spread." Mr Manning blamed a lack of time and resources but also "frankly a lack of focus, a lack of taking it seriously" for individual NHS organisations' failure to keep up with cyber-security improvements. "This was an extremely unsophisticated attack," he added. 
 
The NAO said the NHS "has accepted that there are lessons to learn" from WannaCry and will now develop a response plan. It will also ensure that critical cyber-security updates - such as applying software patches - are carried out by IT staff, the NAO said.
 
WannaCry was "a relatively unsophisticated attack and could have been prevented by the NHS following basic IT security best practice," said Sir Amyas Morse, comptroller and auditor-general of the NAO. "There are more sophisticated cyber-threats out there than WannaCry so the Department and the NHS need to get their act together to ensure the NHS is better protected against future attacks."
 
Keith McNeil, NHS chief clinical information officer for health and care, said: "As the NAO report makes clear, no harm was caused to patients and there were no incidents of patient data being compromised or stolen. "Tried and tested emergency plans were activated quickly and our hard-working NHS staff went the extra mile to provide patient care, keeping the impact on NHS services and patients to a minimum."
 
For many executives, a serious cyber-attack is now very high on their list of risks to their organisations and a priority for disaster planning.
 
So what is most shocking in this report is the lack of planning at a local level in the NHS for such an event. 
To be fair, the Department of Health had developed a plan - it was just that it had not been properly communicated or tested in the NHS trusts. When disaster struck, nobody seemed to know who was in charge or what to do. Of course, all of this could have been avoided if security patches had been applied to protect the Windows 7 systems common throughout the NHS.
 
Once again, there had been warnings sent out by NHS Digital, but many trusts failed to act upon them - though in that they were no different from many organisations around the world that were also hit. In one way, the NHS was lucky - if, instead of a Friday in May, the attack had taken place on a Monday in winter, with a week's appointments affected, the damage would have been far worse.
 
Cybersecurity experts will tell you that dealing with attacks like these is mostly a management rather than a technology problem. And in this case the NHS proved itself incapable of managing a speedy and effective response to its first major cyber-security crisis.
 
Analysis - by Rory Cellan-Jones, BBC technology correspondent
 
BBC
 
You Might Also Read:
 
British NHS Sure To Be Hit By More Cyber Attacks:
 
A New Form Of Ransomware Attacks UK Hospital:
 
 
« A New IoT Botnet Storm Is Coming
‘Bad Rabbit’ Cyber Attack Hits Russia & Ukraine »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

ZenGRC

ZenGRC

ZenGRC - the first, easy-to-use, enterprise-grade information security solution for compliance and risk management - offers businesses efficient control tracking, testing, and enforcement.

CSI Consulting Services

CSI Consulting Services

Get Advice From The Experts: * Training * Penetration Testing * Data Governance * GDPR Compliance. Connecting you to the best in the business.

Clayden Law

Clayden Law

Clayden Law are experts in information technology, data privacy and cybersecurity law.

Syxsense

Syxsense

Syxsense brings together endpoint management and security for greater efficiency and collaboration between IT management and security teams.

Jooble

Jooble

Jooble is a job search aggregator operating in 71 countries worldwide. We simplify the job search process by displaying active job ads from major job boards and career sites across the internet.

Phoenix Datacom Limited

Phoenix Datacom Limited

Phoenix Datacom is a provider of solutions and professional services to improve the performance & security of data centres, networks and applications.

softScheck

softScheck

softScheck is an IT security consultancy. Services range from pentesting and compliance testing to security auditing of software and IT infrastructure.

Cyber Indemnity Solutions (CIS)

Cyber Indemnity Solutions (CIS)

CIS is an InsurTech company focused on licensing innovative cyber risk insurance solutions to the global insurance industry.

Allegro Software

Allegro Software

Allegro provide secure software for the Internet of Things.

Ikarus Security Software

Ikarus Security Software

Ikarus focuses on antivirus and content-security solutions.

Labris Networks

Labris Networks

Labris Networks specializes in DDoS mitigation, NG Firewall, Unified Threat Management, Centralized Management, Regulatory Compliances and SOC/CERT Services.

OmniNet

OmniNet

OmniNet delivers the next generation of cybersecurity and is the only provider in the market to move the edge of small businesses to a virtual, omnipresent perimeter.

NETAS

NETAS

Netas offers solutions in information and communication technologies including end-to-end value added solutions, system integration and technology services to providers and corporations.

S2S Group

S2S Group

S2S Group specialise in the destruction and management of IT assets at the end of the lifecycle.

Africa Cybersecurity and Digital Rights Organisation (ACDRO)

Africa Cybersecurity and Digital Rights Organisation (ACDRO)

ACDRO is a non-governmental Organisation pioneering Digital Rights and promoting cybersecurity awareness within the digital environment in Africa.

CSC Digital Brand Services

CSC Digital Brand Services

Our brand protection and security expertise give our customers peace of mind that no matter how fast the digital world changes, their intellectual property and digital assets will be secure.

Wolverhampton Cyber Research Institute (WCRI)

Wolverhampton Cyber Research Institute (WCRI)

Wolverhampton Cyber Research Institute builds on the strength of its members in the area of network and communication security, artificial intelligence, big data and cyber physical systems.

Constella Intelligence

Constella Intelligence

Constella Intelligence provides digital risk protection services to quickly and efficiently disrupt cyber attacks and data breaches before they occur.

Robo Shadow

Robo Shadow

Robo Shadow are trying to bridge the gap between the top tier organisations that can afford everything and everyone else who has to “Make it up as they go along” when it comes to Cyber.

Celcom

Celcom

Celcom is the oldest mobile telecommunications provider in Malaysia, providing solutions and services to consumers and businesses.

Polestar Industrial IT

Polestar Industrial IT

Polestar work on both sides of the IT & OT divide. Network, Data & Asset Security is our priority. Polestar installations are robust and resilient and comply with the appropriate security.