Difficult: Attracting Women To Cybersecurity

Cybersecurity is a male-dominated field. Women make up only 10% of the global cybersecurity workforce. The field is missing out on a lot of capable people and women are missing out on an interesting, well-paid career path. There have been numerous initiatives trying to change the situation, but fighting existing stereotypes has proven to be hard.

The underlying problem: society still views technology as a ‘boy thing’. Boys are the inventors, the hackers, the tinkerers. We don’t expect girls to have the same interest in building the cool stuff. They are expected to be better at soft skills like empathy, talking and feelings.

These expectations still drive girls toward people-focused careers and away from science and technology, despite all efforts. Or perhaps, ‘despite’ isn’t the right word here…

Don’t Focus Tech

There are several articles that aim to get girls interested in a career in cybersecurity. But even those articles can’t avoid that tech-avoidant girly girl stereotype from popping up from time to time.

It is very telling that the tech part is often assumed to be the ‘bad’ part. It is the part that needs to be sugarcoated somehow. Yes, it is somewhat reluctantly admitted that the field has its roots in technology. But these roots are to blame for the field’s poor reputation. The articles try to lure attention away from this ‘bad’ part by repeating over and over again that the field is so much more than ‘just tech’.

They keep going on about how the field needs to broaden its definition beyond the technical domain and that it is such a misconception to think that cybersecurity is only about keeping information and computers safe. Girls shouldn’t think that the domain is highly technically focused. They must know that cybersecurity is so much more than ‘hacking and passwords’. It is a multidisciplinary field, and if you don’t like tech, there are plenty of non-technical areas to go into as well! And don’t worry; you don’t really need a technical background or technical skills to get a job in cybersecurity.

Looking for tech skills and technical qualifications in cyber candidates is condemned as a bad practice. It ’puts women off’ and even ‘naturally excludes’ them. Girls and tech don’t mix very well, apparently.

Female Skills Wanted

Next to the assumption that you’ll have to downplay the tech part in a career in order to sell it to women, there is the assumption that women will be naturally attracted by the ‘people part’. This is the part that gets advertised as a strong selling point.

These articles point out how professionals in cybersecurity have to deal with all kinds of different people. They argue how important it is to know a thing or two about business and organisational psychology. They stress the field’s connection with fields like behavioral science and politics. And they discuss the need for people who can serve as translators and bridge-builders. That’s where the girls come in, with their naturally superior soft skills as ‘strong communicators and collaborators’.

This is not to downplay the importance of the ‘people part’ in cybersecurity. It is just as important as the tech part. But it is very typical that in articles aimed at women, it’s this people part that gets emphasized over the tech part. This echoes existing stereotypes of tech-avoidant people-oriented females versus technical, tinkering males.

A lot of the opinions expressed in those articles come from women in cybersecurity themselves. But women can have gender prejudices too. These societal expectations are deeply ingrained in us all. And as this blog post shows, it is hard to fight them, even with the best of intentions.

In The Real World

But what if the writers of those articles have intentionally sugarcoated the tech bits? What if they know that that is the only way to get their message across? What if too much talk about tech really does scare the girls away?

The people interviewed in those articles have years of experience as an expert in the field. If there is anybody who knows what works and what doesn’t, it’s them. And probably, they’re right. Emphasizing all the different and interesting social aspects of the field is more likely to draw girls’ attention than talking about technical challenges.

But this preference is, for a large part, the result of the subtle (and not so subtle) messages society keeps sending to girls: You’re a helper, not a tinkerer. A message this kind of article keeps reinforcing.

As long as this keeps happening, things are not going to get any better. If girls keep seeing themselves as non-tech people persons first, they are less likely to choose a career in cybersecurity. Cybersecurity might be broad and multidisciplinary, but it is still a tech field. You work with tech people and you get to deal with tech-related issues. Why go into a tech field when your natural talents lie in an entirely different domain? Not even cybersecurity’s bright career prospects seem enough to change women’s minds about this.

If the field really wants to get more diverse, playing into existing preferences (and reinforcing them) isn’t enough. It’s those preferences themselves that need to be changed. Of course, that is going to be a hell of a job. But unfortunately, no one said that changing the world was going to be easy…

What do you think? Is it realistic to expect those preferences to change anytime soon? Or should the cybersecurity field accept gender preferences as they are today and play into those preferences in order to attract a more diverse workforce?

Medium:      Women In Cybersecurity:


 

« State Sponsored Hackers: Finding The Country Behind The Attack
Cybersecurity Start-Ups Working With GCHQ »

ManageEngine
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Check Point

Directory of Suppliers

CYRIN

CYRIN

CYRIN® Cyber Range. Real Tools, Real Attacks, Real Scenarios. See why leading educational institutions and companies in the U.S. have begun to adopt the CYRIN® system.

Clayden Law

Clayden Law

Clayden Law advise global businesses that buy and sell technology products and services. We are experts in information technology, data privacy and cybersecurity law.

RELIANOID

RELIANOID

RELIANOID provides advanced Application Delivery and integrated security solutions to protect and optimize critical digital services.

Directory of Cyber Security Suppliers

Directory of Cyber Security Suppliers

Our Supplier Directory lists 8,000+ specialist cyber security service providers in 128 countries worldwide. IS YOUR ORGANISATION LISTED?

IT Governance

IT Governance

IT Governance is a leading global provider of information security solutions. Download our free guide and find out how ISO 27001 can help protect your organisation's information.

mile2

mile2

Mile2 develop and deliver proprietary vendor neutral professional certifications for the cyber security industry.

Miller Group

Miller Group

Miller Group is an IT managed service provider. We proactively monitor and manage your entire business computer network. Services include backup & recovery and cyber security.

WizNucleus

WizNucleus

WizNucleus develops, markets and supports a software platform (Cyberwiz-Pro) that enables Critical Infrastructure enterprises to ensure the future state of their cybersecurity and remain compliant.

Industrial Cybersecurity Center (CCI)

Industrial Cybersecurity Center (CCI)

CCI is the first center of its kind that comes from industry without subsidies, independent and non-profit, to promote and contribute to the improvement of Industrial Cybersecurity.

Root9B (R9B)

Root9B (R9B)

R9B offers advanced cybersecurity products, services, and training to enhance the way organizations protect their networks.

Networks Unlimited

Networks Unlimited

Networks Unlimited is a leading value-added distributor in Africa, providing technology solutions with a focus on security, networking, enterprise systems management and cloud technologies.

DataExpert Singapore

DataExpert Singapore

DataExpert Singapore provide solutions and services in the areas of Digital Forensics, Data Recovery, Data Duplication, Data Degaussing & Wiping, Data Destruction, and IT Disposal.

Realsec

Realsec

RealSec is an international company and is a developer of encryption and digital signature systems and Blockchain for the Banking and Methods of Payment sectors, Government and Defense and Multisector

CornerStone

CornerStone

CornerStone is an award winning, independent risk, cyber and security consulting firm providing a range of Risk Management, Security Design and Implementation Management Services.

BalkanID

BalkanID

BalkanID is an Identity governance solution that leverages data science to provide visibility into your SaaS & public cloud entitlement sprawl.

Valtix

Valtix

Valtix is the first and only multi-cloud network security platform delivered as a service that enables cloud teams to meet the most stringent security requirements in a cloud-first & simple way.

Unit 42

Unit 42

Unit 42 brings together world-renowned threat researchers, incident responders and security consultants to create an intelligence-driven, response-ready organization.

CXI Solutions

CXI Solutions

CXI Solutions: Your trusted partner in cybersecurity. We offer a full range of cybersecurity solutions to protect your business from digital attacks and virtual threats.

Seers

Seers

Seers is the world’s leading privacy & consent management platform for companies worldwide. Trusted by over 50,000+ businesses.

Defend

Defend

DEFEND are 100% focused on providing managed cybersecurity solutions and services that make a real difference to the cyber resilience of your organisation.

BreachRx

BreachRx

BreachRx is the first intelligent incident response management platform that provides operational resilience for the entire enterprise.