Five Eyes Intelligence Chiefs Point The Finger

Western countries are naming cyber-attacks by other countries. One of the ideas behind naming and shaming is to discourage cyber-attacks and to encourage potential victims into improve their cyber security strategy and tactics, according to 5Eyes Intel leaders.

Intelligence experts from the Five Eyes Intel group, which is the UK, the USA, Canada, Australia and New Zealand, spoke at CYBERUK 19, the National Cyber Security Centre's (NCSC) cybersecurity conference in Glasgow, in an unusual public discussion.

Recently the Five Eyes have accused some countries of cyber-attacks, such as North Korea and Russia of NotPetya. They group have also accused the Iranian and Chinese governments of hacking.

"There's a small set of nations who are not behaving within international norms," said Rob Joyce, senior cybersecurity advisor for the USA's National Security Agency. 

"If you look at the countries that have blatantly come out and attacked other countries in cyberspace, countries who are stealing wealth to avoid sanctions, literally bank-robbing in the cyber realm, it's a small group, you can name them on one hand," he said.

Joyce said Five Eyes members have "got to get comfortable as nations going out and saying these countries are behaving in a way that's unacceptable and turning up that pressure," adding, "we won't get international norms without being able to speak that truth".

"An important enabling component for making like-minded coalitions is bringing that intelligence forward, doing that attribution and having a specific entity that we have to rally around and deter," said Joyce.

"If we're not talking about the bad actors in this space, we're not going to be able to rally and bring the coalitions, and it's much wider than the Five Eyes."

Some question what real impact calling out attacks in this way can have, but Ciaran Martin, CEO of the NCSC, argued that it makes a difference.

"Do any of us do attribution for its own sake? No, we do it as a means to an end and that end being better cybersecurity and better national security," he said, arguing that it "sometimes" alters the behaviour of attackers, although he did not discuss how this happens. 

Martin told the Glasgow audience that attribution also plays a role in helping organisations protect against potential attacks.

"It matters because we're trying to tell people how to understand risk. So it does help to be able to say what are the Russians interested in, what sort of attacks do they do, what sort of organisations and assets do they tend to be interested in, the same as the Chinese? They're not the same," he said.

"That means you can frame your defence, because some people need to be worried about one country over another, some need to be worried about organised crime, some need to be aware about all of them"

Ultimately, Martin explained, attributing a threat to a particular nation state or malicious actor appears to provide additional incentives for organisations to act on information on how to protect against coming cyber-attacks.

"When we used to put out anonymised, non-attributable attacks, we'd say we'd seen something somewhere and this is how you can fix it, you can get a certain response. When you say this is Russia, you get a bigger response and that does matter," he said.

For all of the Five Eyes nations, attribution is a big deal and the intelligence agencies will only issue public accusations about cyberattacks if they're confident about their conclusions, it's why the official attribution of WannaCry to North Korea only came over six months after the global ransomware attack.

"We'll only attribute an attack to another country if it's within our own national interests to do so," said Jan Thornborough, unit manager of outreach and engagement at New Zealand's National Cyber Security Centre, making four attributions in 18 months.

"We took a lot of time to think about what it means for the country and we were very considerate in the approach," she added.
Australia takes the same approach, ensuring that all the pieces of the puzzle have been put together before public attribution is made.

"Attribution is not trivial: there are people who think they understand attribution and can pull something out and just say something. It's not that easy. We need time for an attribution, it's a very, very high bar for us," said Scott McLeod, first assistant director-general at Protect, Assure & Enable.

Scott Jones, head of the Canadian Centre for Cyber Security, agreed with the idea that attribution must be solid before action is taken. "The bar is very high. We set the bar high for ourselves because we have to have extremely high confidence," he said.

Canada's approach to attribution is the same as that of the US, engaging in order to warn about the actions of nations who are engaging in aggressive behaviour in cyberspace. "The key thing is to say no, this is too far: this is going into a space where this is unacceptable," Jones said.

ZDNet:

You Might Also Read: 

Five Eyes Spies Turn To Commercial Innovation:

 
 
 
« AI Will Shape The Future 6G Network
Cybercrime Cost US Business $2.7B In 2018 »

Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

DigitalStakeout

DigitalStakeout

A simple and cost-effective solution to monitor, investigate and analyze data from the web, social media and cyber sources to identify threats and make better security decisions.

Practice Labs

Practice Labs

Practice Labs is an IT competency hub, where live-lab environments give access to real equipment for hands-on practice of essential cybersecurity skills.

eBook: Practical Guide to Security in the AWS Cloud

eBook: Practical Guide to Security in the AWS Cloud

AWS Marketplace would like to present you with a digital copy of the new book, Practical Guide to Security in the AWS Cloud, by the SANS Institute.

ZenGRC

ZenGRC

ZenGRC - the first, easy-to-use, enterprise-grade information security solution for compliance and risk management - offers businesses efficient control tracking, testing, and enforcement.

XYPRO Technology

XYPRO Technology

XYPRO is the market leader in HPE Non-Stop Security, Risk Management and Compliance.

CSI Consulting Services

CSI Consulting Services

Get Advice From The Experts: * Training * Penetration Testing * Data Governance * GDPR Compliance. Connecting you to the best in the business.

CYRIN

CYRIN

CYRIN® Cyber Range. Real Tools, Real Attacks, Real Scenarios. See why leading educational institutions and companies in the U.S. have begun to adopt the CYRIN® system.

BackupVault

BackupVault

BackupVault is a leading provider of completely automatic, fully encrypted online, cloud backup.

Cylance Smart Antivirus

Cylance Smart Antivirus

An antivirus that works smarter, not harder, from BlackBerry. Lightweight, non-intrusive protection powered by artificial intelligence. BUY NOW - LIMITED DISCOUNT OFFER.

Jooble

Jooble

Jooble is a job search aggregator operating in 71 countries worldwide. We simplify the job search process by displaying active job ads from major job boards and career sites across the internet.

Dataconomy

Dataconomy

Dataconomy is the leading portal for news, events and expert opinion from the world of data driven technology.

Snort

Snort

Snort is an open source intrusion prevention system capable of real-time traffic analysis and packet logging.

Retail & Hospitality Information Sharing & Analysis Center (RH-ISAC)

Retail & Hospitality Information Sharing & Analysis Center (RH-ISAC)

Retail & Hospitality ISAC operates as a central hub for sharing sector-specific cyber security information and intelligence.

Coromatic

Coromatic

As the leading Nordic critical facilities solutions provider, we safeguard continual power supply and data communications.

Jiransoft

Jiransoft

Jiransoft, a security software company, provides endpoint data protection and personal information protection to business users.

Specops Software

Specops Software

Specops Software is a leading password management and authentication solution vendor.

Blockchain Formula

Blockchain Formula

Blockchain Formula are leaders in Blockchain Application Development. Our services have led clients around the globe in innovating blockchain networks and solutions.

Control System Cyber Security Association International (CS2AI)

Control System Cyber Security Association International (CS2AI)

CS2AI is the premier global not for profit workforce development organization supporting professionals of all levels charged with securing control systems.