UK MPs are No longer Exempt from Surveillance

qodimage.php?theme=yougov&numr=5&totalresp=4036&title=a)+Does+it+bother+you+that+intelligence+services+could%2C+if+they+wanted+to%2C+be+spying+on+you+right+now%3F+b)+Do+you+think+they+are+in+fact+spying+on+you+personally+in+any+way%3F&opt1=a)+Yes+b)+Yes&votes1=505&opt2=a)+Yes+b)+No&votes2=1307&opt3=a)+No+b)+Yes&votes3=346&opt4=a)+No+b)+No&votes4=1794&opt5=Don%27t+know&votes5=84

YouGov: UK Public Opinion Divided.

James Eadie QC tells Investigatory Powers Tribunal the Wilson doctrine is unworkable in era of bulk interception by intelligence agencies

U.K. Government lawyers have said it is unfeasible for MPs and members of the Lords to be protected from snooping while there is bulk interception. The 50-year-old political convention that the UK’s intelligence agencies will not intercept the communications of MPs and members of the Lords cannot survive in an age of bulk interception, government lawyers have conceded.

The so-called Wilson doctrine “simply cannot work sensibly” when bulk interception is taking place, James Eadie QC told the investigatory powers tribunal – the court that hears complaints about the intelligence agencies.

Moreover, Eadie said, the doctrine does not have force in law and cannot impose legal restraints on the agencies.
The convention is named after the former Labour Prime Minister Harold Wilson, who told MPs in November 1966 that their phones would not be tapped. Tony Blair subsequently extended it to all forms of electronic communications.
The tribunal, which is being asked to rule that the doctrine is legally enforceable, has already heard that GCHQ changed its guidelines in March, when it decided not to apply the convention to members of the devolved parliaments in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, and members of the European parliament.

That revelation has caused fury among members of those institutions: on Friday, the first minister of Scotland, Nicola Sturgeon, wrote to David Cameron asking for urgent clarification. Sturgeon said she accepted spying on MSPs could take place but only in “truly exceptional circumstances involving national security”. In the vast majority of cases “the confidentiality of communications between parliamentarians and their constituents is of the utmost importance”, she told the prime minister.
 
Labour’s Ian Murray, the shadow Scottish secretary, tabled a series of questions in the Commons asking the prime minister to confirm or deny whether Scottish MSPs, MEPs or Welsh parliamentarians had ever been spied on, and to confirm that GCHQ’s rules had changed.

The complaint at the IPT is being brought by the Green party parliamentarians Caroline Lucas and Lady Jones, and the former Respect MP, George Galloway, who argue that their communications must have been intercepted by the sort of programmes exposed by the CIA whistleblower Edward Snowden.

Eadie conceded that this may have happened under bulk interception operations authorised under the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act (Ripa), but said “there is so much data flowing along the pipe” that it is not examined at the point of interception.
“The interception at that stage isn’t in any event objectionable, if one stands back and takes a broad view of the Wilson doctrine: it isn’t intelligible at the point of interception,” said Eadie.

While ministers have repeatedly reassured MPs and peers that the doctrine remains intact, their statements have been characterised by “ambiguities, at best, whether deliberate or otherwise”, Eadie said. And while the agencies consider the doctrine when drawing up policies governing interception practices, they also require great flexibility. Without this, “national security-critical” practices would become impermissible.
Guardian: http://bit.ly/1gttUth

 

« Fear Killer Robots
Nonstop Cyber Attack - Israel Builds Hack-Proof Defense »

CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

Resecurity, Inc.

Resecurity, Inc.

Resecurity is a cybersecurity company that delivers a unified platform for endpoint protection, risk management, and cyber threat intelligence.

LockLizard

LockLizard

Locklizard provides PDF DRM software that protects PDF documents from unauthorized access and misuse. Share and sell documents securely - prevent document leakage, sharing and piracy.

ManageEngine

ManageEngine

As the IT management division of Zoho Corporation, ManageEngine prioritizes flexible solutions that work for all businesses, regardless of size or budget.

The PC Support Group

The PC Support Group

A partnership with The PC Support Group delivers improved productivity, reduced costs and protects your business through exceptional IT, telecoms and cybersecurity services.

Jooble

Jooble

Jooble is a job search aggregator operating in 71 countries worldwide. We simplify the job search process by displaying active job ads from major job boards and career sites across the internet.

Bob's Business

Bob's Business

Bob's Business adopts a fresh approach to information security awareness and compliance training, delivering key information through the use of short animated movies.

RiskSense

RiskSense

RiskSense empowers enterprises and governments to reveal cyber risk, quickly orchestrate remediation, and monitor the results.

Asvin

Asvin

Asvin provides secure update management and delivery for Internet of Things - IoT Edge devices.

NTIC Cyber Center

NTIC Cyber Center

NTIC Cyber Center is an organization dedicated to making the National Capital Region (Washington DC) more resilient to cyber-attacks.

SecuLetter

SecuLetter

SecuLetter is able to detect unknown attacks with hybrid approaches, static and dynamic analysis.

101 Blockchains

101 Blockchains

101 Blockchains is a professional and trusted provider of enterprise blockchain research and training.

Quantum Security

Quantum Security

Quantum's game-changing approach to cybersecurity brings you performance and peace-of-mind, with a raft of additional benefits: it's non-proprietary, comprehensive, scalable, and affordable.

Penten

Penten

Penten is an Australian-based cyber security company focused on innovation in secure mobility and applied AI (artificial intelligence).

Salvador Technologies

Salvador Technologies

Salvador Technologies provides the world’s fastest technology to recover from cyber-attacks.

GoVanguard

GoVanguard

GoVanguard is an boutique information security team delivering robust, business-focused information security solutions.

Alkira

Alkira

Alkira has reinvented networking for the cloud era by delivering the network cloud, the first global unified network infrastructure with on-demand hybrid and multi-cloud connectivity.

ramsac

ramsac

ramsac provide secure, resilient IT management, cybersecurity, 24 hour support and IT strategy to businesses in London and the South East.

Istari

Istari

ISTARI is a new kind of cyber risk management company. We’re an agile collective of best-in-class capabilities and experts, who build ongoing partnerships with clients.

Siometrix

Siometrix

Siometrix addresses digital identity fraud. It steals your attacker's time and prevents many prevalent attack vectors.

Data Computer Services

Data Computer Services

Data Computer Services provides professional tailored IT Support and IT Services for businesses throughout Edinburgh and the Lothians.

CloudDefense.AI

CloudDefense.AI

CloudDefense.AI is an industry-leading multi-layered Cloud Native Application and Protection Platform (CNAPP) that safeguards your cloud infrastructure and cloud-native apps,