Ukraine Blackout – The Future Of War

For a look at how cyber will play into armed conflict, look at the Dec. 23 attack on the Ukrainian energy sector. This was no simple hack involving celebrity emails or embarrassing personal information, but a highly coordinated and complex cyber-physical assault that knocked out power to more than 225,000 people, in a war-torn country, in the dead of winter.

Recently, the head of Southern Company, one of America’s larger regional electricity producers, said that the United States was well protected against a similar attack. But that doesn’t mean that a repeat, or a similar event, couldn’t trigger a larger conflict even if it doesn’t shut off the lights.

Cyber security researchers have pointed the finger at pro-Russian hacktivist groups. US-based iSight Partners specifically accused the Moscow-based Sandworm. But a wide variety of pro-Russian groups are working against Ukraine and Western forces; one is Cyberberkut, which has taken credit for attacks on German media and NATO sites.

So how do these groups operate? History suggests: with stealth and subtlety.  Remember 2014, when masked gunmen, not officially affiliated with any larger nation-state, began waging war in Eastern Ukraine? The so-called “green men” completed their invasion before anyone was able to figure out that they were, in fact, invading.

The specific culprit in the Ukraine blackout is almost less important than the broader trend: the rise of cyber militias that work on behalf of state interests but whose veneer of independence gives governments plausible deniability.

Tom Kellermann, the CEO of Strategic Cyber Ventures, put it this way at the recent Suits and Spooks conference in Washington, DC. “There’s a cult of personality, particularly in the East. The greatest hackers in the world, the Russian-speaking blackhat community in the former Soviet bloc, are beholden to that cult of personality. They’re beholden to that cult of personality for a number of reasons. They’ve been allowed to act with impunity when hacking the US financial sector for more than 17 years in exchange for paying tribute or homage to the regime. The examples are Estonia, South Ossetia, and now Ukraine.”

But to read the way US outlets covered the Ukrainian outage, you might think that the cyber attack and the blackout occurred almost randomly. In fact, utilities and central services have emerged as a new front in the war in the Eastern part of the country. Less than a month before the Ukrainian energy outage, one occurred on the disputed Crimea peninsula. Ukrainian police blamed saboteurs.

Russian President Vladimir Putin reportedly reacted by promising to construct power lines into the region; Russian newspapers have reported that German company Siemens has a contract with the Russian government to build gas turbine powered-plants in the Crimean cities of Sevastopol and Simferopol. Siemens reportedly refuted the claims, as building the plants would be a violation of international sanctions). Not long after that denial, Siemens became one of the key targets in the Ukraine blackout.  

The primary piece of software implicated in the attack was called BlackEnergy, according to DHS’s recently released report on the incident. It’s less of a weapon than a vehicle carrying a weapon.

The BlackEnergy malware was reportedly delivered via spear phishing emails with malicious Microsoft Office attachments. It is suspected that BlackEnergy may have been used as an initial access vector to acquire legitimate credentials, the report said.

BlackEnergy is still around in 2016 because it has a modular architecture, allowing people to write different plug-ins. By itself, it’s not the sort of software that could take down a power station. Rather, it would work in concert with an add-on, a very specifically designed package; in this case, one designed to attack the control equipment of the targeted Siemens power plants.

Still, recent attacks against US power entities are even more sophisticated than the one against Ukraine. Fanning pointed to a March 2015 attack on a Pacific Gas and Electric substation. The assailants broke into the station physically and then disabled the supervisory control and data acquisition, or SCADA system, before trying to damage other things.

The use of a self-destruct booby trap is the difference between an act of espionage—something that virtually every nation engages in—and an act of serious consequence, possibly requiring international sanctions or a response from US Cyber Command.

Think back to the Sony hack: the attackers not only took data but also destroyed it. “This is why I think many of us worry about Sony, the destructive nature of it. It wasn’t just the fun and games of, you know, what rich Hollywood executives were saying about rich Hollywood starlets, right?” Mike Rogers, the Michigan Republican who used to chair the House Intelligence Committee, said last year. “…That is equally possible in our electric grid.”

If lawmakers decide that the use of software like KillDisk is tantamount to an act of war that could put the military in a difficult position. Adm. Michael Rogers, the head of Cyber Command has said that offensive cyber weapons would be used proportionally and in line with the rules of conflict.

DefenseOne:      The Conversation

« Now Surveillance 'aggressive-invasive': Snowden
Google's AI Wins Final Go Challenge »

Infosecurity Europe
CyberSecurity Jobsite
Perimeter 81

Directory of Suppliers

Jooble

Jooble

Jooble is a job search aggregator operating in 71 countries worldwide. We simplify the job search process by displaying active job ads from major job boards and career sites across the internet.

TÜV SÜD Academy UK

TÜV SÜD Academy UK

TÜV SÜD offers expert-led cybersecurity training to help organisations safeguard their operations and data.

Authentic8

Authentic8

Authentic8 transforms how organizations secure and control the use of the web with Silo, its patented cloud browser.

BackupVault

BackupVault

BackupVault is a leading provider of automatic cloud backup and critical data protection against ransomware, insider attacks and hackers for businesses and organisations worldwide.

Syxsense

Syxsense

Syxsense brings together endpoint management and security for greater efficiency and collaboration between IT management and security teams.

Tripwire

Tripwire

Tripwire are a leading provider of risk-based security, compliance and vulnerability management solutions.

Clifford Chance

Clifford Chance

Clifford Chance are one of the world's pre-eminent law firms with resources across five continents. Practice areas include Cyber Security & Information Protection

National Cybersecurity and Communications Integration Center (NCCIC) - USA

National Cybersecurity and Communications Integration Center (NCCIC) - USA

NCCIC is a cyber situational awareness, incident response, and management center for the US Government, intelligence community, and law enforcement.

ODVA

ODVA

ODVA is a global trade and standards development organization whose members comprise the world’s leading industrial automation companies.

Crossword Cybersecurity

Crossword Cybersecurity

We work with research intensive European university partners to identify promising cyber security intellectual property from research that meets emerging real-world challenges.

Tevora

Tevora

Tevora is a specialized management consultancy focused on cyber security, risk, and compliance services.

QA

QA

QA is a leading IT training provider in the UK with over 1,500 courses covering all areas of IT including Cyber Security.

AlAnsari Technical Solutions (ATS)

AlAnsari Technical Solutions (ATS)

ATS is a Kuwait based company specialised in delivering hardware/software, Virtualisation, IP Telephony / Unified Communication, Networking and professional IT services and solutions.

RCDevs

RCDevs

RCDevs is an award-winning Software company providing security solutions designed for modern enterprise technologies and suited for SMEs to large corporations.

Corsha

Corsha

Corsha is on a mission to simplify API security and allow enterprises to embrace modernization, complex deployments, and hybrid environments with confidence.

Toothpic

Toothpic

ToothPic has invented, designed, developed and patented a solution to enable companies to turn every smartphone into a secure key for a user-friendly online authentication.

PNGCERT

PNGCERT

PNGCERT is the national Computer Emergency Response Team (CERT) for Papua New Guinea.

ManageEngine

ManageEngine

As the IT management division of Zoho Corporation, ManageEngine prioritizes flexible solutions that work for all businesses, regardless of size or budget.

ATSG

ATSG

ATSG is a global leader in transformational technology solutions for today’s digital enterprise. Cybersecurity ranging from Advisory & Assessment to Fully Managed Detection and Response Services.

Unified Solutions

Unified Solutions

Unified Solutions provide a full continuum of cyber security services, compliance, and technology solutions.

Novera

Novera

Novera offer security assessment and advisory services to help businesses manage risks from AI, cyber and privacy.